Divide In Concord
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
Jean Hill, a fiery octogenarian, is deeply concerned about the Great Pacific Garbage Patch, the world's largest landfill. Since 2010, she has spearheaded a grassroots campaign to ban the sale of single-serve plastic bottled water in her hometown of Concord, Massachusetts. She spends her golden years attending city council meetings and cold calling residents. So far, her attempts to pass a municipal bylaw have failed.
As she prepares for one last town meeting, Jean faces the strongest opposition yet, from local merchants and the International Bottled Water Association. But her fiercest challenge comes from Adriana Cohen, mother, model and celebrity publicist-turned-pundit, who insists the bill is an attack on freedom.
When Adriana thrusts Jean's crusade into the national spotlight, it's silver-haired senior versus silver-tongued pro. In the same town that incited the American Revolution and inspired Thoreau's environmental movement, can one senior citizen make history? A tense nail-biter of a vote will decide.
'Divide in Concord is a remarkable, beautifully filmed and presented story of the second great battle of Concord, Massachusetts: the battle to ban small single-serve plastic bottles of water. Watch true community democracy in action as a small group of determined citizens fire another shot heard 'round the world in the name of protecting the global environment and awakening the rest of us to the threat of unsustainable commercial products flooding our stores.' Peter Gleick, President and Co-founder, Pacific Institute, Author, Bottled and Sold: The Story Behind our Obsession with Bottled Water
'The hero is Jean Hill, not a scientist, not a lifelong environmental firebrand 'tree hugger,' but an 80+ year old grandmother, her sturdy sense of American citizenship moving her to carry on a multi-year struggle to ban the bottle. The story of Jean Hill and the fight to ban the sale of bottled water in Concord is an outstanding case study of the kinds of local, grassroots environmental conflicts one sees throughout contemporary American society.' Andrew Szasz, Professor and Chair of Environmental Studies, University of California-Santa Cruz, Author, Shopping Our Way to Safety: How We Changed from Protecting the Environment to Protecting Ourselves
'Would be particularly appropriate for a high school setting since young people are shown voting and playing key roles in the campaign.' Laura Williamson Doyle, Science Books and Films
'Divide in Concord highlights how small groups of committed activists can create real change in their communities. Integrating discussions of history, environmentalism, and community-making, the film touches on issues of sustainability, democracy, and individual choice that are central to conversations in our current moment. By weaving together the story of a small Massachusetts town and the lives of some of its local leaders, the film makes these important issues accessible to students and viewers.' Alissa Cordner, Assistant Professor of Sociology, Whitman College, Co-author, The Civic Imagination: Making a Difference in American Political Life
'An excellent choice to spur classroom discussion of the tensions that arise when environmental issues, civil liberties, and corporate interests converge. The film is appropriate for use in secondary schools, as well as for undergraduate courses in environmental studies, political science, or sociology...A welcome addition for public library collections.' Kathleen Spring, Educational Media Reviews Online
'Showing the complexity of the issue from various angles including conservation, public policy, business, community organizing, media, art, and education, this film would be an excellent one to show to high school or college classes. One could generate exciting in-class discussions and debates, and the film could supply an interesting writing prompt for persuasive essays. Community groups interested in attempting a similar project would learn much from watching the experience of Hill and Appel as they navigate their town's political system.' Cherice Bock, Whole Terrain Journal
'It's entirely fitting that a noteworthy battle over banning the sale of bottled water sales took place in the town known for Thoreau and the start of the Revolutionary War. Divide In Concord presents a fascinating behind-the-scenes look at this conflict, fairly presenting both sides of the issue through interviews with the main participants. This documentary is perfectly suited for classroom use and discussion. The conflict highlighted between environmental protection and individual liberty will surely stay with us for many years to come.' James Salzman, Professor of Law and Environmental Policy, Duke University, Author, Drinking Water: A History
'This is a film after my own heart about sustainability, democracy and the right to know and appreciate the truth about our health in regard to bottled water. One woman's moving plight sets an example of how to take on the bottled water industry one town at a time. Jean Hill's passion and fight will inspire and she will tug at your heartstrings.' Michelle Zurawski, Assistant Professor of Biology, Sustainability Coordinator of Teaching and Learning, Moraine Valley Community College
'Divide in Concord drops the viewer into the middle of a citizen-instigated environmental battle. This most local of efforts provokes a corporate response and nuanced reflections of partisans on sustainability, seemingly small consumer actions and global environmental repercussions, and different conceptions of freedom, choice, and responsibility. The movie offers a deft portrait of local citizen activism, environmentalism, and democracy in action.' William Buzbee, Professor of Law, Georgetown University
'An intimate view of how a few citizens, concerned about the horrific global impact of local habits - buying water in plastic bottles - educated their community to make a change. At the center of the movement is an 84 year old widow and the environmental lessons she learned from her grandson in high school. The film is a tribute to her conviction, bravery, and willingness to persevere in a protracted and exhausting struggle.' Martha Saxton, Professor of History and Sexuality, Women's and Gender Studies, Amherst College
'A perfect blend of harsh realism and inspiring idealism, Divide in Concord has mass appeal and a stirring story.' Anthony Marcusa, Scene Creek
'A close examination of both sides of the conflict...Recommended for high school and public library DVD shelves.' Midwest Book Review
Citation
Main credits
Kaczor, Kris (film director)
Regos, David (film producer)
Luke, Jaedra (film producer)
Other credits
Edited by Steve Nemsick, Matthew Prinzing, Kris Kaczor; musical score by Gigantic Hand; cinematography, Kris Kaczor.
Distributor subjects
Activism; American Democracy; American Studies; Citizenship and Civics; Community; Consumerism; Ecology; Environment; Global Issues; History; Law; Marketing and Advertising; Political Science; Pollution; Recycling; Sociology; Sustainability; Water; Women's StudiesKeywords
WEBVTT
00:00:02.417 --> 00:00:05.876
(MUSIC - \"YANKEE DOODLE\")
00:00:32.918 --> 00:00:37.208
- Yes, I move that the town
vote to ban the sale of water
00:00:37.209 --> 00:00:42.958
in plastic bottles in Concord
starting January 1st, 2011.
00:00:42.959 --> 00:00:47.249
I want to discuss the Great
Pacific Garbage Patch.
00:00:47.250 --> 00:00:48.833
- That\'s way in the Pacific.
00:00:48.834 --> 00:00:49.834
We\'re here in Concord.
00:00:49.834 --> 00:00:50.417
Could you go...
00:00:50.418 --> 00:00:52.791
- I know, but that\'s where
the plastic bottles go.
00:00:52.792 --> 00:00:53.459
- Yep.
00:00:53.459 --> 00:00:54.459
That\'s where they go.
00:00:54.460 --> 00:00:56.334
And could you go on to
the third one, please?
00:01:02.042 --> 00:01:06.416
- I\'ve returned with an article
carefully written as a bylaw.
00:01:06.417 --> 00:01:08.626
I ask for your
support once again.
00:01:12.918 --> 00:01:13.876
- Ms. Hill.
00:01:13.877 --> 00:01:15.416
- Good evening.
00:01:15.417 --> 00:01:17.791
Two years ago, I
began this effort
00:01:17.792 --> 00:01:20.917
because my grandson
Mack told me about
00:01:20.918 --> 00:01:23.666
the disastrous
environmental effect
00:01:23.667 --> 00:01:25.626
of empty plastic bottles.
00:01:46.417 --> 00:01:48.750
- What\'s the problem
with Concord right now?
00:01:48.751 --> 00:01:51.374
- Yeah, there\'s a woman
in town who has...
00:01:51.375 --> 00:01:54.249
for the past three years, she\'s
been trying to ban the sale
00:01:54.250 --> 00:01:55.458
of bottled water.
00:01:55.459 --> 00:01:56.708
- Ban the sale of what?
00:01:56.709 --> 00:01:57.167
(LAUGHTER)
00:01:57.168 --> 00:02:01.625
- I know, I know it sounds
crazy Dan, and I\'m with you.
00:02:01.626 --> 00:02:03.458
She wants to ban the
sale of bottled water...
00:02:03.459 --> 00:02:04.875
- Bottled water?
00:02:04.876 --> 00:02:06.416
- Yes, bottled water.
00:02:06.417 --> 00:02:09.750
(DOORBELL)
00:02:09.751 --> 00:02:12.249
- Hi, would you
sign my petition?
00:02:12.250 --> 00:02:14.124
- Oh, I don\'t agree with that.
00:02:14.125 --> 00:02:14.667
- OK.
00:02:14.668 --> 00:02:15.791
Well, thanks, anyhow.
00:02:15.792 --> 00:02:16.792
Bye.
00:02:21.167 --> 00:02:23.917
- I think of all towns where
freedom should be protected,
00:02:23.918 --> 00:02:26.918
I mean, Concord is where
it should be protected.
00:02:30.792 --> 00:02:33.958
- I\'m back with a bottle ban.
00:02:33.959 --> 00:02:35.999
People sort of flee
when they see me
00:02:36.000 --> 00:02:40.208
because they know they\'re going
to get a little sermonette.
00:02:40.209 --> 00:02:43.917
(DOORBELL)
00:02:43.918 --> 00:02:45.416
- Why in a town like Concord...
00:02:45.417 --> 00:02:47.082
(DOORBELL)
00:02:47.083 --> 00:02:49.041
when we recycle?
00:02:49.042 --> 00:02:50.833
Go find another town
in Massachusetts
00:02:50.834 --> 00:02:52.750
where they\'re not doing
a great job recycling.
00:02:52.751 --> 00:02:55.666
Doesn\'t that make more
sense than removing
00:02:55.667 --> 00:02:58.416
the single most healthy
beverage that\'s contained
00:02:58.417 --> 00:03:00.999
in plastic on the market?
00:03:01.000 --> 00:03:04.999
- Well, she has twins
and she\'s pretty busy.
00:03:05.000 --> 00:03:07.333
She\'s probably in the
middle of giving them
00:03:07.334 --> 00:03:09.541
one of their snacks.
00:03:09.542 --> 00:03:11.292
OK, well, onward and upward.
00:03:15.459 --> 00:03:17.083
I consider myself a warrior.
00:03:19.709 --> 00:03:22.208
I live in Concord
and I\'m trying to get
00:03:22.209 --> 00:03:24.708
plastic water bottles banned.
00:03:24.709 --> 00:03:29.917
And warriors have to be
prepared for any enemy.
00:03:29.918 --> 00:03:31.791
Boy, it\'s a mess in there.
00:03:31.792 --> 00:03:33.999
Looks like someone\'s
just moved in.
00:03:34.000 --> 00:03:36.998
I think I\'ll skip this one.
00:03:36.999 --> 00:03:39.958
- These ideas that
we can actually
00:03:39.959 --> 00:03:44.708
have free choice in what
we buy and how we shop,
00:03:44.709 --> 00:03:48.542
they\'re under attack right
now by one bill, one person.
00:03:54.209 --> 00:03:55.458
- She\'s a prophet.
00:03:55.459 --> 00:03:58.291
People think prophets are crazy.
00:03:58.292 --> 00:04:00.583
But honestly, over
time, you think
00:04:00.584 --> 00:04:02.208
they\'re less crazy
because you realize
00:04:02.209 --> 00:04:04.333
they\'re on to something.
00:04:04.334 --> 00:04:06.541
- I\'m no prophet.
00:04:06.542 --> 00:04:10.375
I\'m the right person, and
this is the right time.
00:04:21.375 --> 00:04:24.082
- My name is Eric Van Loon.
00:04:24.083 --> 00:04:27.374
I\'m the elected town
moderator here in Concord.
00:04:27.375 --> 00:04:30.999
(MUSIC PLAYING)
00:04:31.000 --> 00:04:34.626
Concord is a very special
community in American history.
00:04:38.000 --> 00:04:41.459
There were lots of reasons to be
attracted to living in Concord.
00:04:52.542 --> 00:04:55.082
- This cheese will reportedly
be the largest wheel
00:04:55.083 --> 00:04:58.041
of Italian cheese anywhere
in the Western hemisphere.
00:04:58.042 --> 00:05:00.998
(CROWD CHEERING)
00:05:00.999 --> 00:05:04.833
- We have everything from
Walden Pond and Luisa May Alcott
00:05:04.834 --> 00:05:10.082
to Ralph Waldo Emerson
and Henry David Thoreau,
00:05:10.083 --> 00:05:14.583
plus the key role that Concord
played in the Revolutionary War
00:05:14.584 --> 00:05:17.041
once the embattled farmers
stood and fired the shot heard
00:05:17.042 --> 00:05:20.125
round the world at the old North
Bridge a half mile from here.
00:05:33.083 --> 00:05:36.541
- I think it really
started in Lexington,
00:05:36.542 --> 00:05:39.208
but then it came to Concord.
00:05:39.209 --> 00:05:43.042
And Concord was where they
stood up against the British.
00:05:52.042 --> 00:05:56.208
\"By the rude bridge
that arched the flood,
00:05:56.209 --> 00:06:01.208
their flag to April\'s
breeze unfurled.
00:06:01.209 --> 00:06:04.875
Here, once, the
embattled farmer stood...
00:06:04.876 --> 00:06:05.792
- Raise arms.
00:06:05.792 --> 00:06:06.292
- Raise arms.
00:06:06.293 --> 00:06:12.042
- and fired the shot
heard \'round the world.\"
00:06:19.125 --> 00:06:21.166
I find that very moving.
00:06:21.167 --> 00:06:24.999
To me, it symbolizes the
same thing that I\'m doing.
00:06:25.000 --> 00:06:28.708
And so it\'ll be the second
shot heard \'round the world.
00:06:28.709 --> 00:06:31.333
That\'s pretty corny,
but it will be.
00:06:31.334 --> 00:06:36.458
I\'m doing it because I know
it\'s right and I know it\'s just.
00:06:36.459 --> 00:06:37.292
- Over here, ma\'am.
00:06:37.292 --> 00:06:38.083
Have a seat.
00:06:38.084 --> 00:06:39.166
- Thank you, sir.
00:06:39.167 --> 00:06:40.125
- Yeah, you\'re welcome.
00:06:40.126 --> 00:06:41.166
Take care of yourself.
00:06:41.167 --> 00:06:42.167
- I will.
00:06:59.375 --> 00:07:02.708
I\'m Jean Hill, and
this is where I live.
00:07:02.709 --> 00:07:07.541
The address is 24 Concord
Green, Apartment 5.
00:07:07.542 --> 00:07:10.291
And I\'ve been living
here quite a long time
00:07:10.292 --> 00:07:11.584
and I like it very much.
00:07:24.999 --> 00:07:25.959
Here it is.
00:07:25.960 --> 00:07:29.333
Oh, I remember this so well.
00:07:29.334 --> 00:07:33.791
This is 73 Monument Street,
where my husband and I raised
00:07:33.792 --> 00:07:34.792
our four children.
00:07:37.667 --> 00:07:40.917
My husband died in \'06.
00:07:40.918 --> 00:07:45.875
For a year, I was
mourning, but after
00:07:45.876 --> 00:07:50.082
that I realized that for
the first time in my life
00:07:50.083 --> 00:07:54.541
I was not responsible to
anyone and I could do anything
00:07:54.542 --> 00:07:56.166
I pleased.
00:07:56.167 --> 00:07:59.583
I didn\'t have to do any
cooking for my kids,
00:07:59.584 --> 00:08:02.791
I didn\'t have to worry
about my husband.
00:08:02.792 --> 00:08:06.541
And I liked that,
but I did find it
00:08:06.542 --> 00:08:10.750
necessary to find
some kind of activity.
00:08:10.751 --> 00:08:12.833
And that\'s when
I started working
00:08:12.834 --> 00:08:14.334
against plastic bottles.
00:08:18.000 --> 00:08:19.458
My grandson, Mack...
00:08:19.459 --> 00:08:21.875
(MUSIC PLAYING)
00:08:21.876 --> 00:08:25.958
I was visiting their house one
day and Mack said, \"You know,
00:08:25.959 --> 00:08:30.750
Grandma, there are big bunches
of plastic in the ocean
00:08:30.751 --> 00:08:32.374
and it\'s really terrible.\"
00:08:32.375 --> 00:08:35.541
He was a smart little kid and
he looked it up on the computer.
00:08:35.542 --> 00:08:38.542
You\'re the source
of all this trouble.
00:08:42.042 --> 00:08:45.791
Then I started thinking on
it and using the internet
00:08:45.792 --> 00:08:46.792
to get information.
00:08:49.918 --> 00:08:54.998
This is the Great
Pacific Garbage Patch.
00:08:54.999 --> 00:08:56.875
There it is.
00:08:56.876 --> 00:08:59.708
And it is an amazing mass.
00:08:59.709 --> 00:09:04.417
Look at the size of those gyres,
and there are so many of them.
00:09:12.999 --> 00:09:14.791
Do you have the
Concord Journal yet?
00:09:14.792 --> 00:09:16.416
- Yes, ma\'am, right
on the bottom shelf.
00:09:16.417 --> 00:09:17.417
- OK.
00:09:20.542 --> 00:09:23.249
You have the best
butcher in town.
00:09:23.250 --> 00:09:24.541
- Thank you very much.
00:09:24.542 --> 00:09:25.625
- Now I need that penny...
00:09:25.626 --> 00:09:26.542
- Thank you very much.
00:09:26.543 --> 00:09:27.833
- because every penny helps.
00:09:27.834 --> 00:09:28.751
- Absolutely.
00:09:28.752 --> 00:09:30.333
There you go, you
gave me one too many.
00:09:30.334 --> 00:09:30.876
Thank you.
00:09:30.876 --> 00:09:31.542
- Thank you.
00:09:31.542 --> 00:09:32.417
- Bye, now.
00:09:32.417 --> 00:09:33.417
- Bye-bye.
00:09:36.250 --> 00:09:39.791
\"Bottled water debate resumes.\"
00:09:39.792 --> 00:09:42.374
The more ink you
get, the better.
00:09:42.375 --> 00:09:44.125
On and on the debate goes.
00:09:48.167 --> 00:09:51.583
- Democracy is alive and well
in Concord, and lots of people
00:09:51.584 --> 00:09:54.166
have points of
views on everything
00:09:54.167 --> 00:09:58.374
and they\'re all very articulate.
00:09:58.375 --> 00:10:02.374
- As a community, there\'s no
community in the United States
00:10:02.375 --> 00:10:04.124
that\'s ever made
a community choice
00:10:04.125 --> 00:10:08.209
to eliminate a product such
as single serve bottled water.
00:10:10.584 --> 00:10:14.541
- People want to drink
water, and as a merchant
00:10:14.542 --> 00:10:17.416
it\'s my job to give
people what they want.
00:10:17.417 --> 00:10:21.876
The packaging is not as
important as the product.
00:10:24.959 --> 00:10:26.958
- This land has
been in agriculture
00:10:26.959 --> 00:10:30.416
back before the
settlers came, and it
00:10:30.417 --> 00:10:33.374
seems the Indians didn\'t have
a very good immigration policy
00:10:33.375 --> 00:10:36.333
and they lost the land
to some of the intruders.
00:10:36.334 --> 00:10:41.666
And this was part of the land
taken by the King of England
00:10:41.667 --> 00:10:44.458
when they came.
00:10:44.459 --> 00:10:48.374
76 years I\'ve lived in Concord,
which actually is about
00:10:48.375 --> 00:10:50.125
a fifth of the town\'s history.
00:10:53.876 --> 00:10:56.416
I\'m opposed to the
bottled water ban,
00:10:56.417 --> 00:10:59.750
I think that people should be
able to make their own choice.
00:10:59.751 --> 00:11:02.249
I don\'t drink it, never
bought a bottle in my life.
00:11:02.250 --> 00:11:04.375
But I think people
should be able to choose.
00:11:08.876 --> 00:11:11.875
- Imagine how our Founding
Fathers would feel now if after
00:11:11.876 --> 00:11:13.625
writing the Declaration
of Independence...
00:11:13.626 --> 00:11:17.249
Which talks about life, liberty,
and the pursuit of happiness...
00:11:17.250 --> 00:11:18.917
If they heard hundreds
of years later,
00:11:18.918 --> 00:11:21.249
you wouldn\'t even have the
freedom to even be able to buy
00:11:21.250 --> 00:11:22.666
water.
00:11:22.667 --> 00:11:24.791
It\'s not crack or heroin.
00:11:24.792 --> 00:11:25.626
It\'s water.
00:11:25.627 --> 00:11:27.459
Let\'s keep this in
perspective, OK?
00:11:29.417 --> 00:11:32.082
- It\'s also, I think, a
pretty slippery slope when
00:11:32.083 --> 00:11:38.917
you start trying to make
healthy legal items illegal.
00:11:38.918 --> 00:11:40.875
I don\'t know where it
starts and where it ends,
00:11:40.876 --> 00:11:43.249
but I think it\'s a
pretty slippery slope
00:11:43.250 --> 00:11:47.082
to start to take away the
freedom of choice for people.
00:11:47.083 --> 00:11:50.542
(DRUM ROLL)
00:11:51.000 --> 00:11:54.459
(MUSIC PLAYING)
00:12:00.876 --> 00:12:04.166
- Live free or die,
because death is not
00:12:04.167 --> 00:12:06.082
the worst of all evils.
00:12:06.083 --> 00:12:09.082
Slavery is.
00:12:09.083 --> 00:12:10.583
(GUNSHOT)
00:12:10.584 --> 00:12:13.999
(CAR ALARM)
00:12:17.334 --> 00:12:20.708
- I\'m Chuck Hacala, captain of
the Bedford Minutemen Company.
00:12:20.709 --> 00:12:23.833
We are here today for the
Meriam Corner Exercise,
00:12:23.834 --> 00:12:26.082
and our company is specifically
invited to this event
00:12:26.083 --> 00:12:28.041
because we carry the
Bedford flag, which
00:12:28.042 --> 00:12:32.041
was the only flag carried at
the Battle of Concord in 1775.
00:12:32.042 --> 00:12:35.124
We have lots of things, lots of
laws that attack our freedoms.
00:12:35.125 --> 00:12:38.625
I can\'t just go out and drive
200 miles an hour in my car.
00:12:38.626 --> 00:12:41.082
I would like to have
that freedom, maybe,
00:12:41.083 --> 00:12:45.833
but we decide as
a group that, no,
00:12:45.834 --> 00:12:47.666
we\'re going to actually
put in some laws
00:12:47.667 --> 00:12:50.666
that limit our
behaviors but in what we
00:12:50.667 --> 00:12:51.833
consider a positive way.
00:12:51.834 --> 00:12:55.082
So I think, again, it\'s
up to the people that
00:12:55.083 --> 00:12:57.791
want to ban the bottles
to convince the larger
00:12:57.792 --> 00:13:01.998
community that this is
really good for everybody.
00:13:01.999 --> 00:13:04.666
And if they can
convince enough people,
00:13:04.667 --> 00:13:06.917
then I think it\'s perfectly
fine to ban something
00:13:06.918 --> 00:13:08.416
like bottled water.
00:13:08.417 --> 00:13:14.208
- Well, what I\'m doing is I have
a petition Article, number 32
00:13:14.209 --> 00:13:17.875
on the town warrant,
and that is to ban
00:13:17.876 --> 00:13:20.708
the sale of drinking
water in plastic bottles
00:13:20.709 --> 00:13:21.833
in the town of Concord.
00:13:21.834 --> 00:13:23.708
- I don\'t think we have
that kind of problem.
00:13:23.709 --> 00:13:24.791
I think those have
been overblown a lot
00:13:24.792 --> 00:13:25.998
in the last several years.
00:13:25.999 --> 00:13:28.208
Why put more burdens of
people than they already have?
00:13:28.209 --> 00:13:33.374
- Well, because only
20% of the plastic water
00:13:33.375 --> 00:13:35.082
bottles are recycled.
00:13:35.083 --> 00:13:36.333
- How do we know that, though?
00:13:36.334 --> 00:13:38.750
What\'s our statistics for that?
00:13:38.751 --> 00:13:41.416
- You can find out a lot
about all these issues
00:13:41.417 --> 00:13:44.124
if you go to Corporate
Accountability
00:13:44.125 --> 00:13:46.458
International in Boston.
00:13:46.459 --> 00:13:51.999
They have tobacco...
00:13:52.000 --> 00:13:54.750
things...
00:13:54.751 --> 00:13:56.082
what did you do?
00:13:56.083 --> 00:13:57.998
Why did you kill that bug?
00:13:57.999 --> 00:14:00.666
Well, I don\'t want
to argue with you.
00:14:00.667 --> 00:14:01.958
- No, I don\'t either.
00:14:01.959 --> 00:14:02.417
- But...
00:14:02.418 --> 00:14:04.124
- I would say you\'re
probably the Goliath
00:14:04.125 --> 00:14:05.875
and I think the Davids
are the folks that
00:14:05.876 --> 00:14:09.333
are going to probably
want to drink their water.
00:14:09.334 --> 00:14:11.958
- No.
00:14:11.959 --> 00:14:17.666
- We\'ll proceed initially with
the discussion of Article 38.
00:14:17.667 --> 00:14:18.125
- Hello?
00:14:18.125 --> 00:14:19.083
Oh.
00:14:19.084 --> 00:14:20.583
(LAUGHTER)
00:14:20.584 --> 00:14:21.542
- Hello.
00:14:21.543 --> 00:14:23.833
- OK, I guess it\'s on.
00:14:23.834 --> 00:14:25.082
- Please identify yourself.
00:14:25.083 --> 00:14:29.082
- I\'m Jean Hill, and I
live at 24 Concord Green.
00:14:29.083 --> 00:14:33.374
- And I\'m Jill Appel, and I
live at 244 Caterina Heights.
00:14:33.375 --> 00:14:34.000
- We\'re a team.
00:14:34.001 --> 00:14:35.166
- Thank you very much.
00:14:35.167 --> 00:14:37.416
- I\'m the perspiration,
she\'s the inspiration.
00:14:37.417 --> 00:14:39.541
(MUSIC PLAYING)
00:14:39.542 --> 00:14:42.166
When I first met
Jean, I wasn\'t really
00:14:42.167 --> 00:14:47.416
compelled to think of bottled
water in the way that I do now.
00:14:47.417 --> 00:14:50.041
People said, \"Oh, bottled
water, bottled water, what
00:14:50.042 --> 00:14:52.041
a small thing\", and
\"You\'re not going
00:14:52.042 --> 00:14:54.249
to make a big difference\",
and things like that.
00:14:54.250 --> 00:14:58.917
And I have to admit my first
reaction also was, jeez,
00:14:58.918 --> 00:15:00.166
what are we talking about here?
00:15:00.167 --> 00:15:02.124
You know, water in
plastic bottles?
00:15:02.125 --> 00:15:04.082
Come on.
00:15:04.083 --> 00:15:06.166
But throughout my
research I guess
00:15:06.167 --> 00:15:10.625
I found that bottled water
is really the epitome,
00:15:10.626 --> 00:15:14.166
it is the poster child
for unsustainability.
00:15:14.167 --> 00:15:16.998
And the more I learned
about the issue,
00:15:16.999 --> 00:15:19.998
the more I realized that
she\'s got something.
00:15:19.999 --> 00:15:21.750
It\'s really important.
00:15:21.751 --> 00:15:23.833
Even when you can
make a small change,
00:15:23.834 --> 00:15:27.082
that small change could
have a big impact.
00:15:27.083 --> 00:15:30.041
- I think Jill realized
that I needed help,
00:15:30.042 --> 00:15:35.917
because I\'m a loner and she
knows the way the town works.
00:15:35.918 --> 00:15:37.082
She\'s much better at that.
00:15:37.083 --> 00:15:40.374
So we make... together
we make a very good team.
00:15:40.375 --> 00:15:41.999
- We\'re both strong women.
00:15:42.000 --> 00:15:44.666
When I get out of
line, Jean\'ll tell me.
00:15:44.667 --> 00:15:45.584
And when Jean...
00:15:45.585 --> 00:15:49.374
when I need to rope
Jean in, I\'ll tell her.
00:15:49.375 --> 00:15:52.041
So I think there\'s a
lot of mutual respect.
00:15:52.042 --> 00:15:55.625
- Because I have the passion
and she has the know-how,
00:15:55.626 --> 00:15:57.291
and that works.
00:15:57.292 --> 00:15:59.998
- I think this is a time
where one community can
00:15:59.999 --> 00:16:02.082
put its foot down
and say \"We\'re going
00:16:02.083 --> 00:16:04.208
to take a stand
against this product
00:16:04.209 --> 00:16:06.999
because it\'s an
unsustainable product.\"
00:16:07.000 --> 00:16:09.416
I think the time is right.
00:16:09.417 --> 00:16:10.998
Good morning, Jean!
00:16:10.999 --> 00:16:11.876
- Good morning, Jill.
00:16:11.876 --> 00:16:12.459
- How are you?
00:16:12.460 --> 00:16:14.208
- Here, I\'m all set
for the coordinations.
00:16:14.209 --> 00:16:16.541
- I heard, I called ahead.
00:16:16.542 --> 00:16:19.416
My focus is more at
the community level,
00:16:19.417 --> 00:16:23.041
because you have to think global
but work at the local level
00:16:23.042 --> 00:16:24.124
to make things happen.
00:16:24.125 --> 00:16:26.374
And I guess within
the town of Concord,
00:16:26.375 --> 00:16:28.750
I feel there\'s a
good community that\'s
00:16:28.751 --> 00:16:31.333
supportive of
environmental issues.
00:16:31.334 --> 00:16:32.958
This is the kind of
place where we can
00:16:32.959 --> 00:16:34.125
get some of this stuff done.
00:16:39.125 --> 00:16:40.999
Thank you so much
for coming today.
00:16:41.000 --> 00:16:42.917
And thank you for
participating in this,
00:16:42.918 --> 00:16:44.541
because I think we
have an opportunity
00:16:44.542 --> 00:16:46.041
to really make history here.
00:16:46.042 --> 00:16:51.291
The Article that we\'ve got this
year is basically the same.
00:16:51.292 --> 00:16:54.333
It still focuses on
single serve bottles only,
00:16:54.334 --> 00:16:55.708
of one liter or less.
00:16:55.709 --> 00:16:59.416
So the gallon jugs are not
covered by the Article.
00:16:59.417 --> 00:17:02.917
There still is an
exemption for emergencies.
00:17:02.918 --> 00:17:05.291
The deal on this is
not about the fines,
00:17:05.292 --> 00:17:09.998
it\'s about making a statement
about an unsustainable product
00:17:09.999 --> 00:17:12.917
that we would choose not
to have in our community.
00:17:12.918 --> 00:17:17.166
So our goal this year is to
really reach out and just get
00:17:17.167 --> 00:17:18.249
votes.
00:17:18.250 --> 00:17:20.958
- Each person has their
own circle of friends.
00:17:20.959 --> 00:17:24.875
And so if you can spread
the word among your friends,
00:17:24.876 --> 00:17:26.041
that\'ll be a big help.
00:17:26.042 --> 00:17:30.208
- The idea is that we\'re quietly
going about gathering votes
00:17:30.209 --> 00:17:31.917
from sympathetic people.
00:17:31.918 --> 00:17:33.458
We appreciate your
coming tonight
00:17:33.459 --> 00:17:36.751
and look forward to working
with you on the campaign.
00:17:39.876 --> 00:17:42.666
- One of the key features
of Town Meeting...
00:17:42.667 --> 00:17:45.208
And this goes back
in Massachusetts law
00:17:45.209 --> 00:17:49.458
and the Constitution for
really hundred of years...
00:17:49.459 --> 00:17:53.708
Is the right of individual
citizens to bring a measure
00:17:53.709 --> 00:17:55.416
to a vote at Town Meeting.
00:17:55.417 --> 00:17:57.458
And the bar is very, very low.
00:17:57.459 --> 00:18:01.166
10 signatures is all that\'s
required to get a warrant
00:18:01.167 --> 00:18:04.625
Article before the town.
00:18:04.626 --> 00:18:07.998
- Well, I\'m tickled that
I got so many signatures.
00:18:07.999 --> 00:18:11.249
Many more than I need.
00:18:11.250 --> 00:18:18.708
The minimum is 10, but I
got much more than that.
00:18:18.709 --> 00:18:19.375
Hello, Anita.
00:18:19.375 --> 00:18:20.209
- How are you doing?
00:18:20.209 --> 00:18:21.167
Nice to see you again.
00:18:21.168 --> 00:18:24.583
Stamp them in for you, so that
we know that you\'ve got them
00:18:24.584 --> 00:18:25.334
in on time...
00:18:25.335 --> 00:18:26.583
- Yup.
00:18:26.584 --> 00:18:29.999
- by the deadline,
and this looks great.
00:18:30.000 --> 00:18:31.249
Best of luck with this, Jean.
00:18:31.250 --> 00:18:31.792
- Thank you.
00:18:31.792 --> 00:18:32.292
- And it was nice to see you.
00:18:32.292 --> 00:18:32.834
- Thank you.
00:18:32.834 --> 00:18:33.542
- And happy new year.
00:18:33.542 --> 00:18:34.042
- Bye-bye,
00:18:34.043 --> 00:18:35.791
- Bye, Arlene.
00:18:35.792 --> 00:18:37.083
Well, that\'s done.
00:18:42.709 --> 00:18:45.249
Now I just have to finish it.
00:18:45.250 --> 00:18:48.709
(MUSIC PLAYING)
00:18:52.125 --> 00:18:53.999
- When I think back to
the Founding Fathers
00:18:54.000 --> 00:18:55.999
and the radical thought
that was going on there,
00:18:56.000 --> 00:18:59.082
these are people who realized
the world was changing.
00:18:59.083 --> 00:19:01.625
And they wanted to change
it into a better place.
00:19:01.626 --> 00:19:03.917
They were leaving behind
the feudal system,
00:19:03.918 --> 00:19:08.249
the absolute monarchal systems
that had dominated in Europe,
00:19:08.250 --> 00:19:10.875
and saying \"We need
a new world order.\"
00:19:10.876 --> 00:19:13.208
And they were radicals, that\'s
what they\'re fighting for.
00:19:13.209 --> 00:19:16.166
They were fighting for ideals.
00:19:16.167 --> 00:19:17.958
I\'m Bob Lawson.
00:19:17.959 --> 00:19:20.374
- I\'m Bill Turville.
00:19:20.375 --> 00:19:23.291
This is our sculpture.
00:19:23.292 --> 00:19:26.751
Bob\'s idea, my assistance
in realizing it.
00:19:29.125 --> 00:19:32.124
- My concept of putting
together the sculpture...
00:19:32.125 --> 00:19:35.249
right now, it\'s really
to support Jean\'s Article
00:19:35.250 --> 00:19:37.625
and I hope it helps
that thing pass.
00:19:37.626 --> 00:19:40.708
When this is finished, it\'ll
be comprised of 1,500 water
00:19:40.709 --> 00:19:43.124
bottles... 1,500.
00:19:43.125 --> 00:19:44.791
And that\'s the number
that are consumed
00:19:44.792 --> 00:19:49.374
every second in the United
States, just the United States
00:19:49.375 --> 00:19:50.625
alone.
00:19:50.626 --> 00:19:54.041
Every second of every day, all
these bottles and the ones you
00:19:54.042 --> 00:19:56.458
saw on the wall there
came from one family...
00:19:56.459 --> 00:19:59.998
One family... who recycles
them, but I would get to...
00:19:59.999 --> 00:20:02.166
I noticed how many they were
getting rid of every week
00:20:02.167 --> 00:20:04.291
and I would get there before
the recycling truck came.
00:20:04.292 --> 00:20:05.917
And I would just
take their recycling,
00:20:05.918 --> 00:20:07.917
and I\'d throw them in my thing.
00:20:07.918 --> 00:20:10.998
We\'re not the radicals.
00:20:10.999 --> 00:20:15.082
Just like Jean... the people,
Jean Hill, and Jill Appel,
00:20:15.083 --> 00:20:17.166
and everyone who\'s
going to vote for them,
00:20:17.167 --> 00:20:19.249
they are not the radicals.
00:20:19.250 --> 00:20:20.833
The radicals are
the people who think
00:20:20.834 --> 00:20:26.333
that we can alter the chemistry
of our Earth, for profit.
00:20:26.334 --> 00:20:26.876
For profit.
00:20:26.877 --> 00:20:28.583
This is what this
is, this is profit.
00:20:28.584 --> 00:20:30.708
These companies
need to sell more.
00:20:30.709 --> 00:20:32.999
They couldn\'t sell more
Coke and Pepsi and all that,
00:20:33.000 --> 00:20:34.250
so they decided to sell water.
00:20:40.834 --> 00:20:43.208
- What\'s the first reason I\'m
helping out in the campaign?
00:20:43.209 --> 00:20:44.583
Well, the first reason I\'m
helping out in the campaign
00:20:44.584 --> 00:20:46.291
is because my
mother asked me to.
00:20:46.292 --> 00:20:49.584
(LAUGHTER)
00:20:51.959 --> 00:20:55.625
People are already dying
from climate change,
00:20:55.626 --> 00:20:57.999
and people are already
suffering from climate change,
00:20:58.000 --> 00:20:59.708
and it\'s going to
get a lot worse.
00:20:59.709 --> 00:21:02.833
You have to say, when
people talk about choice,
00:21:02.834 --> 00:21:05.166
and \"I\'d like to be able to
go down buy bottled water\"...
00:21:05.167 --> 00:21:07.208
you don\'t make a
choice in a vacuum.
00:21:07.209 --> 00:21:09.333
- I think we have to have
some component within
00:21:09.334 --> 00:21:11.291
the presentation that
talks about litigation...
00:21:11.292 --> 00:21:11.918
- Yeah.
00:21:11.919 --> 00:21:13.791
- and I think we ought to
make it clear to the people
00:21:13.792 --> 00:21:15.416
in the room that we
expect to get sued.
00:21:15.417 --> 00:21:15.959
(LAUGHTER)
00:21:15.960 --> 00:21:18.249
- All right, well, if you are
going to make that point I
00:21:18.250 --> 00:21:21.708
think you should not fail to
underline we\'re being picked
00:21:21.709 --> 00:21:23.999
on by a giant bully who\'s
much more powerful...
00:21:24.000 --> 00:21:26.333
- That\'s right, and Concord
doesn\'t respond well
00:21:26.334 --> 00:21:27.458
to bullies.
00:21:27.459 --> 00:21:30.625
- I thought of a visual of the
bottled water industry dressed
00:21:30.626 --> 00:21:34.166
in red coats shooting bottled
water saying \"Drink up,
00:21:34.167 --> 00:21:34.709
Concord.
00:21:34.710 --> 00:21:36.124
Or else.\"
00:21:36.125 --> 00:21:37.125
And I just...
00:21:37.126 --> 00:21:40.124
I like that kind of
visual piece because I
00:21:40.125 --> 00:21:41.917
think we have to come
right out and say,
00:21:41.918 --> 00:21:45.625
we had some bullies
in here 200 years ago.
00:21:45.626 --> 00:21:46.750
All right, do the math.
00:21:46.751 --> 00:21:47.375
250 years ago...
00:21:47.375 --> 00:21:48.375
- And we\'ll be firing...
00:21:48.375 --> 00:21:49.167
- whatever.
00:21:49.168 --> 00:21:51.833
- We\'ll be firing the second
shot heard \'round the world.
00:21:51.834 --> 00:21:53.709
- And are we going to
let them intimidate us?
00:21:57.292 --> 00:21:59.792
(MUSIC PLAYING)
00:22:04.959 --> 00:22:06.416
It\'s a big industry.
00:22:06.417 --> 00:22:08.625
It\'s a big industry to
try and... you know,
00:22:08.626 --> 00:22:10.249
it\'s David and Goliath here.
00:22:10.250 --> 00:22:10.792
- Yeah.
00:22:10.793 --> 00:22:13.416
Well, do you look at the
size of their postcards?
00:22:13.417 --> 00:22:14.583
Last year, we sent one out.
00:22:14.584 --> 00:22:15.999
It was this big.
00:22:16.000 --> 00:22:18.666
And their postcard was
this big last year.
00:22:18.667 --> 00:22:20.708
Now it\'s even bigger and
there are three of them.
00:22:20.709 --> 00:22:21.375
- This is power.
00:22:21.375 --> 00:22:21.999
This is power.
00:22:21.999 --> 00:22:22.626
- Yeah, really.
00:22:22.626 --> 00:22:23.125
We\'re big.
00:22:23.125 --> 00:22:23.751
We\'re powerful.
00:22:23.752 --> 00:22:25.458
We\'re going to take
up your whole mailbox.
00:22:25.459 --> 00:22:27.625
- And we\'re going to send
two of them to every...
00:22:27.626 --> 00:22:28.791
- It\'s kind of intimidating.
00:22:28.792 --> 00:22:30.750
- Just got this in
the mail yesterday.
00:22:30.751 --> 00:22:33.666
And so, they\'re coming up
with some pretty big graphics
00:22:33.667 --> 00:22:35.124
and really trying
to catch your eye.
00:22:35.125 --> 00:22:37.583
And that\'s why I\'m trying
to catch some eyes too,
00:22:37.584 --> 00:22:39.041
to counteract this.
00:22:39.042 --> 00:22:42.124
But this is what we\'re
dealing with in Concord now.
00:22:42.125 --> 00:22:43.999
It\'s getting hot
and heavy this week.
00:22:44.000 --> 00:22:45.625
- But you can see they\'re
working at every demographic
00:22:45.626 --> 00:22:46.375
here.
00:22:46.375 --> 00:22:47.000
- Yeah.
00:22:47.000 --> 00:22:48.000
- Let\'s get the...
00:22:48.001 --> 00:22:49.374
- Oh, yeah, look at this.
00:22:49.375 --> 00:22:52.249
The moms, the soccer
moms, the kids.
00:22:52.250 --> 00:22:54.249
- I\'m a little alarmed
to see all the ads
00:22:54.250 --> 00:22:54.876
that have come around.
00:22:54.876 --> 00:22:55.626
Did you see the...
00:22:55.627 --> 00:22:56.791
- Well, they always do that.
00:22:56.792 --> 00:22:57.083
It\'s...
00:22:57.083 --> 00:22:57.626
- Do they?
00:22:57.627 --> 00:22:59.541
The postcards that
came to all of us?
00:22:59.542 --> 00:23:00.999
- all of it, propaganda.
00:23:01.000 --> 00:23:01.584
- Oh my gosh.
00:23:01.585 --> 00:23:03.541
It\'s like 8 and a 1/2 by 11\".
00:23:03.542 --> 00:23:04.334
- Yeah, it\'s huge.
00:23:04.334 --> 00:23:05.334
- \"A ban will cost...\"
00:23:05.335 --> 00:23:07.875
Oh, we\'re looking
at the cost angle.
00:23:07.876 --> 00:23:10.291
Oh my gosh.
00:23:10.292 --> 00:23:14.082
Concord has a history
of not giving in,
00:23:14.083 --> 00:23:16.124
as the seat of the
American Revolution.
00:23:16.125 --> 00:23:19.998
I mean, the penalty at that
point in time was death.
00:23:19.999 --> 00:23:22.041
You know, I mean you
went out with your musket
00:23:22.042 --> 00:23:24.082
and you didn\'t know whether
you were coming back.
00:23:24.083 --> 00:23:27.124
And here we\'re talking
about bottled water,
00:23:27.125 --> 00:23:29.124
for crying out loud.
00:23:29.125 --> 00:23:32.417
(MUSIC PLAYING)
00:23:34.292 --> 00:23:37.583
- I think the story concerning
Jean Hill and her request
00:23:37.584 --> 00:23:40.917
to ban the sale of bottled water
in the town really goes back
00:23:40.918 --> 00:23:45.374
two years, and a Town Meeting we
had two years ago seemed to me
00:23:45.375 --> 00:23:47.208
to be very pro-environment.
00:23:47.209 --> 00:23:49.583
- I\'ve brought my
own here tonight,
00:23:49.584 --> 00:23:51.082
filled from the kitchen tap.
00:23:51.083 --> 00:23:53.833
- However Jean\'s
article, as you know,
00:23:53.834 --> 00:23:55.541
had some flaws in
the writing of it
00:23:55.542 --> 00:23:57.208
and the Attorney
General of Massachusetts
00:23:57.209 --> 00:23:59.791
found that it was unenforceable.
00:23:59.792 --> 00:24:03.583
And then in 2011, Jean
resubmitted the article.
00:24:03.584 --> 00:24:05.999
The mood of Town
Meeting had changed.
00:24:06.000 --> 00:24:08.416
- and what democracy
means to me is freedom.
00:24:08.417 --> 00:24:10.999
And one of those core
freedoms is for Americans
00:24:11.000 --> 00:24:15.041
to be able to choose what it is
they eat, drink, and consume.
00:24:15.042 --> 00:24:18.541
- Jean, as determined as she
is, this is her life\'s work
00:24:18.542 --> 00:24:20.998
and this is her
major contribution.
00:24:20.999 --> 00:24:23.416
And she\'s determined
to go back this year.
00:24:23.417 --> 00:24:24.375
- Good morning.
00:24:24.376 --> 00:24:28.791
Last year, I believe that I
had enough supporters to win.
00:24:28.792 --> 00:24:33.166
However the vote was not called
until very late, by which time
00:24:33.167 --> 00:24:35.875
my weary supporters
had departed.
00:24:35.876 --> 00:24:38.791
- Town Meeting is very
much by the people
00:24:38.792 --> 00:24:40.833
and of the people for sure.
00:24:40.834 --> 00:24:44.750
It\'s one of the oldest forms of
government in the United States
00:24:44.751 --> 00:24:46.958
and yet, except for
here in New England,
00:24:46.959 --> 00:24:49.208
most people don\'t
really know about it.
00:24:49.209 --> 00:24:56.917
On Article 38, the vote in favor
was 265... the vote opposed,
00:24:56.918 --> 00:24:58.750
272.
00:24:58.751 --> 00:25:01.625
So it fails to pass
by seven votes.
00:25:01.626 --> 00:25:04.959
(APPLAUSE)
00:25:07.334 --> 00:25:11.458
- So I lost by seven votes.
00:25:11.459 --> 00:25:15.291
I can remember Jill just... she
was so disappointed she just
00:25:15.292 --> 00:25:16.917
ran out.
00:25:16.918 --> 00:25:20.458
And I just sat there stunned.
00:25:20.459 --> 00:25:23.708
- We can be fierce as
lions if we\'re challenged,
00:25:23.709 --> 00:25:27.291
and we will stand our ground
as we have done in the past,
00:25:27.292 --> 00:25:28.791
and we will triumph in the end.
00:25:28.792 --> 00:25:31.750
And I just want to
say congratulations
00:25:31.751 --> 00:25:34.583
to Jean Hill, who\'s worked
so hard for so long,
00:25:34.584 --> 00:25:36.541
and I hope we see her next year.
00:25:36.542 --> 00:25:37.542
Thank you.
00:25:41.125 --> 00:25:45.417
- I am going on
this journey again.
00:25:55.959 --> 00:25:58.083
Some of these trees or so old.
00:26:12.417 --> 00:26:15.791
- Town Manager serves as chief
executive officer for the town,
00:26:15.792 --> 00:26:18.333
and I work for a
five member elected,
00:26:18.334 --> 00:26:21.917
non-paid Board of Selectmen,
who jointly share executive
00:26:21.918 --> 00:26:23.208
authority with the Town Manager.
00:26:23.209 --> 00:26:26.583
And I\'ve been in my job here
in Concord for about 18 years.
00:26:26.584 --> 00:26:28.208
I have gone back
and forth on it,
00:26:28.209 --> 00:26:32.291
because I\'m sympathetic with the
local merchants in particular,
00:26:32.292 --> 00:26:35.666
and we really want
to try to keep
00:26:35.667 --> 00:26:37.291
shopping viable in Concord.
00:26:37.292 --> 00:26:38.209
We\'re a small town.
00:26:38.210 --> 00:26:41.166
It\'s tough for small
merchants to make a go of it
00:26:41.167 --> 00:26:43.333
with such a small
population base.
00:26:43.334 --> 00:26:48.333
My prediction is... I
guess if asked today,
00:26:48.334 --> 00:26:51.750
five months before Town
Meeting convenes...
00:26:51.751 --> 00:26:54.333
That they would probably
be predisposed to say that
00:26:54.334 --> 00:26:55.583
we\'ve already discussed this.
00:26:55.584 --> 00:26:57.416
We decided last year
we don\'t want to do it,
00:26:57.417 --> 00:27:00.291
and we still don\'t
want to do it.
00:27:00.292 --> 00:27:02.416
- The room across the hall
is the Selectmen\'s room,
00:27:02.417 --> 00:27:04.041
and that\'s where the
Board of Selectmen
00:27:04.042 --> 00:27:07.998
meet and make the executive
decisions on a weekly basis.
00:27:07.999 --> 00:27:12.166
Their meetings are recorded
and rebroadcast on TV.
00:27:12.167 --> 00:27:14.541
- and also our snow and
ice account seems to still be
00:27:14.542 --> 00:27:15.334
in good shape.
00:27:15.335 --> 00:27:17.416
(LAUGHTER)
00:27:17.417 --> 00:27:20.750
- You\'re not relinquishing
it yet, however, right?
00:27:20.751 --> 00:27:24.124
It being a couple of
minutes past 8:00,
00:27:24.125 --> 00:27:28.416
I\'m going to skip ahead on
the agenda to the presentation
00:27:28.417 --> 00:27:31.416
on Article 32 by Jean Hill.
00:27:31.417 --> 00:27:35.208
- This year\'s presentation
will be similar to last year\'s
00:27:35.209 --> 00:27:38.333
and will reflect the
feedback we received.
00:27:38.334 --> 00:27:39.998
- You know, I think
the important thing
00:27:39.999 --> 00:27:42.791
to know about the Article
is that it\'s really not
00:27:42.792 --> 00:27:43.875
about the fines.
00:27:43.876 --> 00:27:47.583
It\'s really about the
community making a choice
00:27:47.584 --> 00:27:48.375
around this product.
00:27:48.376 --> 00:27:49.875
- Changing behavior and
changing the culture.
00:27:49.876 --> 00:27:51.249
- Changing behavior
with something
00:27:51.250 --> 00:27:54.666
that sticks, and
that\'s meaningful.
00:27:54.667 --> 00:27:55.584
- Thank you very much.
00:27:55.584 --> 00:27:56.334
- OK, great.
00:27:56.335 --> 00:27:57.791
Appreciate your
coming in tonight.
00:27:57.792 --> 00:27:58.751
- Thank you very much.
00:27:58.751 --> 00:27:58.790
- Thanks, Jill.
00:27:58.791 --> 00:28:00.791
- And we will be taking a
position at a future meeting.
00:28:00.792 --> 00:28:01.626
- Thank you for letting us come.
00:28:01.626 --> 00:28:02.083
- Admire your persistence.
00:28:02.084 --> 00:28:04.082
- Look forward to
seeing you again.
00:28:04.083 --> 00:28:08.208
- Well I\'m 84 and I\'m still
going, so I hope to...
00:28:08.209 --> 00:28:08.918
- Keep it up.
00:28:08.918 --> 00:28:09.626
We appreciate it.
00:28:09.627 --> 00:28:11.333
- Time is a winged
chariot at my heels.
00:28:11.334 --> 00:28:14.709
(LAUGHTER)
00:28:16.667 --> 00:28:20.000
- The industry has been
active yet not visible.
00:28:23.709 --> 00:28:26.416
My belief is they\'re
using our local... well,
00:28:26.417 --> 00:28:28.166
he actually doesn\'t
live in town...
00:28:28.167 --> 00:28:32.791
The owner of our local grocery
store to make their case.
00:28:32.792 --> 00:28:37.541
The local grocery store now
has a big bottled water vending
00:28:37.542 --> 00:28:41.541
area with cases of single
serve bottled water,
00:28:41.542 --> 00:28:44.166
as well as apparently
a big poster
00:28:44.167 --> 00:28:47.998
on why people are supposed
to vote against Article 32,
00:28:47.999 --> 00:28:50.708
because it\'s going to
hurt local businesses.
00:28:50.709 --> 00:28:52.958
The owner of the
store is Jim Crosby.
00:28:52.959 --> 00:28:55.416
The name of the store
is Crosby\'s Market.
00:28:55.417 --> 00:28:58.959
(MUSIC PLAYING)
00:29:13.834 --> 00:29:16.999
- Hi I\'m Jim Crosby, I own and
operate Crosby\'s Marketplace
00:29:17.000 --> 00:29:18.082
in Concord, Mass.
00:29:18.083 --> 00:29:20.291
We\'ve been there
for 32 years, and we
00:29:20.292 --> 00:29:23.541
appreciate your business.
00:29:23.542 --> 00:29:25.666
We\'re a fairly small store,
so this is pretty much
00:29:25.667 --> 00:29:29.416
our water display.
00:29:29.417 --> 00:29:32.791
But I mean, everything that
isn\'t gallons or two and a half
00:29:32.792 --> 00:29:34.998
gallons is all single serve.
00:29:34.999 --> 00:29:38.333
So basically all of this,
all of this, all of that
00:29:38.334 --> 00:29:40.875
would be under one liter.
00:29:40.876 --> 00:29:42.458
I\'m the chair of the
Massachusetts Food
00:29:42.459 --> 00:29:45.625
Association this year.
00:29:45.626 --> 00:29:47.082
I\'ll retire after this year.
00:29:47.083 --> 00:29:51.374
Well, it represents really
the entire industry.
00:29:51.375 --> 00:29:54.041
And it\'s a
legislative area where
00:29:54.042 --> 00:29:56.666
we\'ll look for things that
we have a common desire.
00:29:56.667 --> 00:29:59.541
Last year, it was increasing
the number of liquor licenses
00:29:59.542 --> 00:30:03.416
that were available for food
stores from three to five.
00:30:03.417 --> 00:30:05.958
This year, the major focus
is on eliminating the need
00:30:05.959 --> 00:30:08.166
to price every single
item in the store.
00:30:08.167 --> 00:30:10.291
It\'s issues like that
that I think we all
00:30:10.292 --> 00:30:13.875
have a common desire.
00:30:13.876 --> 00:30:16.249
I have mixed emotions of even
getting involved with this,
00:30:16.250 --> 00:30:18.458
but I do think that
it\'s dangerous enough
00:30:18.459 --> 00:30:20.666
to try to take a position.
00:30:20.667 --> 00:30:22.751
I run a certain amount
of personal risk with it.
00:30:35.083 --> 00:30:39.041
- Next on our agenda, we have
response to the plastic bottle
00:30:39.042 --> 00:30:40.998
warrant article.
00:30:40.999 --> 00:30:43.541
And Mr. Jim Crosby
of Crosby\'s Market
00:30:43.542 --> 00:30:45.082
is here to speak with us.
00:30:45.083 --> 00:30:46.750
- Thank you for the opportunity.
00:30:46.751 --> 00:30:49.124
Basically, being in the
business for 50 years,
00:30:49.125 --> 00:30:51.416
I can assure you
that this could cause
00:30:51.417 --> 00:30:54.291
some really serious damage
to the local businesses
00:30:54.292 --> 00:30:56.291
in Concord.
00:30:56.292 --> 00:30:59.958
Water is a huge category
now, and growing tremendously
00:30:59.959 --> 00:31:01.666
over the last decade.
00:31:01.667 --> 00:31:05.208
It\'s 30% of the entire
beverage category.
00:31:05.209 --> 00:31:09.998
And of the water category, 50%
is in the single serve water
00:31:09.999 --> 00:31:12.333
size under one liter.
00:31:12.334 --> 00:31:14.833
People in Concord, as you
know, are very active:
00:31:14.834 --> 00:31:17.999
They walk, they jog,
they are into athletics,
00:31:18.000 --> 00:31:19.708
they march in parades.
00:31:19.709 --> 00:31:22.041
And the single serve
water, obviously,
00:31:22.042 --> 00:31:24.625
is the most efficient
and most convenient
00:31:24.626 --> 00:31:27.082
form for people to hydrate.
00:31:27.083 --> 00:31:29.833
I\'d ask your consideration
in certainly not recommending
00:31:29.834 --> 00:31:30.958
this.
00:31:30.959 --> 00:31:33.998
- I\'m curious, have
you been approached
00:31:33.999 --> 00:31:37.875
by anybody from the
bottle industry on this?
00:31:37.876 --> 00:31:41.166
- Well, I am aware of the
International Bottle Water
00:31:41.167 --> 00:31:45.708
Association, in terms
of their concern.
00:31:45.709 --> 00:31:48.458
You\'re dealing with some fairly
heavy companies... Nestle,
00:31:48.459 --> 00:31:52.875
Coke, Pepsi, those
particular organizations.
00:31:52.876 --> 00:31:55.417
But beyond that, I don\'t
really have any knowledge of...
00:31:58.042 --> 00:31:59.875
- OK, so you\'re not
speaking for them?
00:31:59.876 --> 00:32:00.834
- Oh, absolutely not.
00:32:00.835 --> 00:32:02.583
- You\'re speaking on behalf
of Crosby\'s Market...
00:32:02.584 --> 00:32:02.876
- That\'s right.
00:32:02.877 --> 00:32:03.999
- and other local merchants.
00:32:04.000 --> 00:32:05.000
- Right.
00:32:08.792 --> 00:32:12.666
- I find it amazing
that Jim Crosby
00:32:12.667 --> 00:32:15.041
is inflammatory
toward us and we are
00:32:15.042 --> 00:32:16.999
so afraid to go back at them.
00:32:17.000 --> 00:32:19.998
- Crosby is not the
bottled water industry.
00:32:19.999 --> 00:32:22.458
- He is now gone to
the Board of Selectmen,
00:32:22.459 --> 00:32:24.583
he\'s been on the
front page, he\'s
00:32:24.584 --> 00:32:26.208
written a letter to the editor.
00:32:26.209 --> 00:32:30.291
- I\'m not saying that it\'s
not appalling that he\'s...
00:32:30.292 --> 00:32:32.333
- He\'s the front man
for the industry.
00:32:32.334 --> 00:32:33.334
- We can\'t prove that...
00:32:33.335 --> 00:32:35.541
- Why else would he come out...?
00:32:35.542 --> 00:32:38.875
- well, it is going to
be bad for his business.
00:32:38.876 --> 00:32:41.708
- Why would he come out
in such a formal way?
00:32:41.709 --> 00:32:44.917
Perhaps he\'s getting a lot of
pressure from the industry.
00:32:44.918 --> 00:32:47.791
I mean, it\'s a very visible
step forward that he\'s taken.
00:32:47.792 --> 00:32:49.999
We never saw him last year.
00:32:50.000 --> 00:32:52.167
We never even saw him.
00:32:57.042 --> 00:33:01.917
- I\'m determined that
this bottle ban will pass.
00:33:01.918 --> 00:33:05.958
What happens is that once
we do that, other towns will
00:33:05.959 --> 00:33:07.666
say, \"Well, we can do it.
00:33:07.667 --> 00:33:09.458
If Concord did it,
we can do it too.\"
00:33:09.459 --> 00:33:12.999
And it will spread like
a stone in the water,
00:33:13.000 --> 00:33:15.791
and the rings going around it.
00:33:15.792 --> 00:33:18.374
Thanks so much for
having this party, Peggy.
00:33:18.375 --> 00:33:20.082
- Well, it\'s fun to
sit on the stone wall
00:33:20.083 --> 00:33:22.166
and watch the parade go by.
00:33:22.167 --> 00:33:25.291
- Oh I know, and you\'re
so nice to have us here.
00:33:25.292 --> 00:33:27.082
- Well, I\'m wishing
you luck on...
00:33:27.083 --> 00:33:28.583
- You know what.
00:33:28.584 --> 00:33:30.666
- down at Town Meeting.
00:33:30.667 --> 00:33:34.958
- Well I wouldn\'t say that
Jean Hill is a typical Concord
00:33:34.959 --> 00:33:37.249
resident, but I would
say that there\'s
00:33:37.250 --> 00:33:41.374
a long history of
individual citizens
00:33:41.375 --> 00:33:45.583
who feel strongly about an
issue and bringing it forward
00:33:45.584 --> 00:33:46.375
to Town Meeting.
00:33:46.376 --> 00:33:50.625
And I mentioned
last year, the woman
00:33:50.626 --> 00:33:53.417
who brought the right to dry
clothes on a clothesline.
00:33:58.125 --> 00:34:02.541
- (SINGING) The answer my
friends is blowing in the wind.
00:34:02.542 --> 00:34:07.917
The answer is
blowing in the wind.
00:34:07.918 --> 00:34:12.666
Take a picture of my
flag, the tattered Earth.
00:34:12.667 --> 00:34:17.249
My name is Peggy Brace, lived
in Concord for about 35 years,
00:34:17.250 --> 00:34:21.249
and presented an article at
Town Meeting two years ago
00:34:21.250 --> 00:34:23.291
on the right to dry clothes.
00:34:23.292 --> 00:34:27.416
And it passed with
flying colors.
00:34:27.417 --> 00:34:30.625
Because this is our own
single house, we can dry here.
00:34:30.626 --> 00:34:33.791
There\'s no problem with
me drying my clothes here.
00:34:33.792 --> 00:34:38.917
But people who live in condos
or restricted communities can\'t.
00:34:38.918 --> 00:34:41.458
And it seems horrendous
that you\'re not
00:34:41.459 --> 00:34:45.458
allowed to save energy,
against the law to save energy.
00:34:45.459 --> 00:34:49.291
I mean, in this day and age,
it doesn\'t make too much sense.
00:34:49.292 --> 00:34:54.625
So this is for other people
who don\'t have the permission
00:34:54.626 --> 00:34:56.583
to hang up.
00:34:56.584 --> 00:34:59.999
My grandmother dried
laundry, my mother did,
00:35:00.000 --> 00:35:04.082
and I just instinctively
always hung out the laundry.
00:35:04.083 --> 00:35:06.583
I think it takes about
a minute and a half
00:35:06.584 --> 00:35:09.998
to do a pair of sheets,
and about four minutes
00:35:09.999 --> 00:35:13.082
for a big huge
load, so what are we
00:35:13.083 --> 00:35:16.124
doing that we can\'t take
five minutes out of our life
00:35:16.125 --> 00:35:19.374
to hang up the laundry?
00:35:19.375 --> 00:35:23.583
Here\'s Betty White
from television,
00:35:23.584 --> 00:35:27.208
and Jean Hill who\'s
into the bottle bill,
00:35:27.209 --> 00:35:28.833
and a sketch of me.
00:35:28.834 --> 00:35:31.625
The artist had never seen me
and there\'s no pictures of me
00:35:31.626 --> 00:35:34.708
in the paper so I don\'t know how
they knew what I looked like,
00:35:34.709 --> 00:35:38.875
but it\'s kind of nice haircut
and a nice blue dress.
00:35:38.876 --> 00:35:43.041
This appeared in the Sunday
Globe, \"Grand Ambitions.\"
00:35:43.042 --> 00:35:47.416
This is somebody who wrote
about Concord ladies trying
00:35:47.417 --> 00:35:49.541
to change the world.
00:35:49.542 --> 00:35:50.833
- Hello?
00:35:50.834 --> 00:35:51.542
- Jill?
00:35:51.542 --> 00:35:52.000
- Yes?
00:35:52.001 --> 00:35:53.750
- Hi, this is Jean Hill calling.
00:35:53.751 --> 00:35:54.584
- Hi.
00:35:54.585 --> 00:35:57.249
- I know that your
position in the past
00:35:57.250 --> 00:36:00.666
has been in opposition
to my bottle bill.
00:36:00.667 --> 00:36:01.958
- It still is.
00:36:01.959 --> 00:36:03.291
- And it still is.
00:36:03.292 --> 00:36:07.208
Are you aware that the
permafrost in the North Pole
00:36:07.209 --> 00:36:08.541
has melted?
00:36:08.542 --> 00:36:10.625
- And banning water
bottles in Concord
00:36:10.626 --> 00:36:11.833
is not going to cure it.
00:36:11.834 --> 00:36:14.958
- Well it\'s going to help,
because the bottle...
00:36:14.959 --> 00:36:15.876
- No, Jean.
00:36:15.877 --> 00:36:19.124
We need to do this as a
whole world and nation.
00:36:19.125 --> 00:36:21.458
- Well, we do have
to do it gradually.
00:36:21.459 --> 00:36:26.583
- Yeah, but I think doing it
in Concord is not my style.
00:36:26.584 --> 00:36:27.917
- OK, well that\'s all right.
00:36:27.918 --> 00:36:28.417
I understand.
00:36:28.418 --> 00:36:29.791
- Have fun without me.
00:36:29.792 --> 00:36:31.041
- OK, happy new year.
00:36:31.042 --> 00:36:31.876
- Happy new year.
00:36:31.876 --> 00:36:32.876
Bye.
00:36:32.877 --> 00:36:35.583
- Asshole.
00:36:35.584 --> 00:36:37.083
How do I get the
hell out of here?
00:36:40.000 --> 00:36:42.291
Eventually I will.
00:36:42.292 --> 00:36:43.541
That\'s life.
00:36:43.542 --> 00:36:49.875
And if you want to do
something worthwhile
00:36:49.876 --> 00:36:57.876
you have to expect rebuttals,
and you have to work at it
00:36:58.042 --> 00:37:00.583
and have a thick skin.
00:37:00.584 --> 00:37:04.291
But my feeling is that
I want to be all used up
00:37:04.292 --> 00:37:07.666
before I go on to
another world where there
00:37:07.667 --> 00:37:09.999
are no plastic water bottles.
00:37:10.000 --> 00:37:12.791
- I like bottled water and I
like having it as an option.
00:37:12.792 --> 00:37:15.249
If Jean Hill and
her supporters want
00:37:15.250 --> 00:37:19.291
to move our town forward and
attain sustainability, live
00:37:19.292 --> 00:37:21.583
a greener life, they should
have figured out a way
00:37:21.584 --> 00:37:25.416
to bring us all together in the
circle instead of polarizing
00:37:25.417 --> 00:37:28.791
and dividing this community.
00:37:28.792 --> 00:37:31.124
- Make sure you use
your table of contents
00:37:31.125 --> 00:37:33.708
to sequence the
pages in your binder.
00:37:33.709 --> 00:37:34.875
- Can we...
00:37:34.876 --> 00:37:36.374
- Get out there and
find some leaves.
00:37:36.375 --> 00:37:37.375
- Thank you!
00:37:39.792 --> 00:37:41.333
- For the first time
in history, we\'re
00:37:41.334 --> 00:37:43.249
presented with a new
situation happening
00:37:43.250 --> 00:37:44.750
in the world\'s oceans.
00:37:44.751 --> 00:37:46.583
There\'s a new flavor
in the food chain
00:37:46.584 --> 00:37:49.541
and it\'s not too
appetizing: plastic.
00:37:49.542 --> 00:37:53.999
In the ocean, there are rotating
ocean currents known as gyres.
00:37:54.000 --> 00:37:56.917
But along with these
swirling wonders of the sea,
00:37:56.918 --> 00:38:00.374
there\'s a new resident...
Trash, trash, and more trash.
00:38:00.375 --> 00:38:05.166
The Great Pacific Garbage
Patch is the main culprit here.
00:38:05.167 --> 00:38:07.750
Yes, it\'s the largest
landfill in the world,
00:38:07.751 --> 00:38:10.249
in the middle of the ocean.
00:38:10.250 --> 00:38:12.708
And the new meal
in town is plastic,
00:38:12.709 --> 00:38:16.583
making up 90% of the
trash in the ocean.
00:38:16.584 --> 00:38:19.208
Most of the debris in the
garbage patch is composed
00:38:19.209 --> 00:38:22.625
of small plastic pieces
suspended in the upper water
00:38:22.626 --> 00:38:25.625
column... difficult to see,
even with the human eye.
00:38:25.626 --> 00:38:27.917
The plastic breaks down
into tiny particles
00:38:27.918 --> 00:38:31.374
and then it\'s consumed
by ocean life.
00:38:31.375 --> 00:38:33.082
So what does this mean?
00:38:33.083 --> 00:38:35.998
Well, let\'s just say this
A host of other animals,
00:38:35.999 --> 00:38:39.875
including humans, will ingest
this trash via the food chain.
00:38:39.876 --> 00:38:42.666
So let\'s remember: just
because it\'s out of sight,
00:38:42.667 --> 00:38:43.751
it\'s not out of mind.
00:38:47.667 --> 00:38:49.958
- Oh, and there\'s an
environmental club.
00:38:49.959 --> 00:38:51.291
That\'s great!
00:38:51.292 --> 00:38:55.791
- So there was a stigma
around using tap water
00:38:55.792 --> 00:38:58.416
at the high school, and
the hydration station
00:38:58.417 --> 00:39:00.374
has really taken that away.
00:39:00.375 --> 00:39:04.291
Here\'s a hydration station
outside the main office.
00:39:04.292 --> 00:39:09.333
It saved the equivalent of
11,545 bottles of water.
00:39:09.334 --> 00:39:11.333
And it\'s chilled
and it\'s filtered,
00:39:11.334 --> 00:39:13.249
and it really changed
the way people
00:39:13.250 --> 00:39:14.625
drink at the high school.
00:39:14.626 --> 00:39:16.249
- \"Trash Talk.\"
00:39:16.250 --> 00:39:18.917
Wow, this school
is really grooving.
00:39:18.918 --> 00:39:21.082
They\'re on a roll.
00:39:21.083 --> 00:39:25.124
- The idea is not to redo
what we did last year,
00:39:25.125 --> 00:39:28.708
but to have something more
focused, more effective,
00:39:28.709 --> 00:39:32.124
to get the votes that we need
at Town Meeting in April.
00:39:32.125 --> 00:39:35.875
- And also it\'s a year later,
so now at least I\'ll be 18,
00:39:35.876 --> 00:39:38.082
and a lot of my friends
will be 18 as well.
00:39:38.083 --> 00:39:41.750
So we\'ll have a little more say
in it and we can now vote, too.
00:39:41.751 --> 00:39:42.459
That was really...
00:39:42.459 --> 00:39:43.083
- Oh, that\'s right.
00:39:43.084 --> 00:39:45.541
- that was really aggravating
because Maggie and I were
00:39:45.542 --> 00:39:50.124
so for this Article passing,
but we couldn\'t actually vote.
00:39:50.125 --> 00:39:51.625
- You have four of
them, and that\'s
00:39:51.626 --> 00:39:53.333
where you spent your
money from the grant?
00:39:53.334 --> 00:39:54.250
- Mm-hmm.
00:39:54.250 --> 00:39:55.000
- Good for you.
00:39:55.001 --> 00:39:56.917
(LAUGHTER)
00:39:56.918 --> 00:39:59.082
- So you just place your
bottle right there...
00:39:59.083 --> 00:40:01.334
- And there it
goes, automatically.
00:40:04.167 --> 00:40:06.875
- OK, and now...
00:40:06.876 --> 00:40:09.917
and I can also not only
get water from here,
00:40:09.918 --> 00:40:11.042
but I can get it from here.
00:40:15.125 --> 00:40:16.791
It\'s delicious.
00:40:16.792 --> 00:40:20.209
(LAUGHTER)
00:40:22.209 --> 00:40:24.791
Best water I\'ve ever had.
00:40:24.792 --> 00:40:26.208
The young people
are the ones who
00:40:26.209 --> 00:40:29.249
are going to have to
think about the future.
00:40:29.250 --> 00:40:33.333
They\'ll have to take
over from the older folks
00:40:33.334 --> 00:40:39.958
to work for environmental issues
and all other things that will
00:40:39.959 --> 00:40:42.541
make the world a better place.
00:40:42.542 --> 00:40:43.834
- I\'m going to go in the front.
00:40:46.542 --> 00:40:47.958
Bye, Maggie.
00:40:47.959 --> 00:40:49.291
Next year.
00:40:49.292 --> 00:40:52.666
- Here we go, off to
town hall to vote.
00:40:52.667 --> 00:40:55.583
- So why are you
registering to vote?
00:40:55.584 --> 00:40:57.708
- First because I
haven\'t registered yet,
00:40:57.709 --> 00:41:01.875
so I can vote in the primaries
and in the bottled water
00:41:01.876 --> 00:41:04.041
banning.
00:41:04.042 --> 00:41:06.834
That\'s why we\'re here, because
we\'re informed citizens.
00:41:12.792 --> 00:41:13.417
Oh, there it is.
00:41:13.418 --> 00:41:16.541
- \"Water quality of
Concord Public Works\".
00:41:16.542 --> 00:41:17.083
OK.
00:41:17.084 --> 00:41:20.999
This is the water quality annual
report for Concord\'s water,
00:41:21.000 --> 00:41:22.333
I guess.
00:41:22.334 --> 00:41:25.416
There are no violations
in our water.
00:41:25.417 --> 00:41:28.166
We\'re here to register to vote.
00:41:28.167 --> 00:41:30.374
- Would it be too late
to switch to Independent
00:41:30.375 --> 00:41:31.917
so I can vote tomorrow?
00:41:31.918 --> 00:41:33.082
- Please sign here.
00:41:33.083 --> 00:41:35.750
- But as of today, you\'re
registered for Town Meeting.
00:41:35.751 --> 00:41:36.709
- Thank you so much.
00:41:36.709 --> 00:41:37.375
- You\'re welcome.
00:41:37.375 --> 00:41:38.375
Have a good day.
00:41:40.375 --> 00:41:41.209
- Good job!
00:41:41.210 --> 00:41:46.041
- So now is everyone going
to vote for my Article
00:41:46.042 --> 00:41:47.708
to ban bottled water?
00:41:47.709 --> 00:41:50.124
- Heck, yeah!
00:41:50.125 --> 00:41:51.751
- Heck yeah, you are!
00:42:01.626 --> 00:42:04.791
- Every Town Meeting has
local customs and procedures
00:42:04.792 --> 00:42:08.998
that reflect the character and,
yes, sometimes the characters
00:42:08.999 --> 00:42:09.999
of your community.
00:42:16.792 --> 00:42:19.541
- I\'m Ed Newman, the moderator
from Stow, Massachusetts.
00:42:19.542 --> 00:42:21.124
In the next few
minutes, we\'ll learn
00:42:21.125 --> 00:42:23.626
about the document used in Town
Meeting called the warrant.
00:42:28.167 --> 00:42:32.625
- The basic process is that
individuals submit articles
00:42:32.626 --> 00:42:36.458
for the town warrant, and
it\'s a published document
00:42:36.459 --> 00:42:38.541
that is mailed to
every household
00:42:38.542 --> 00:42:40.998
within the town of Concord.
00:42:40.999 --> 00:42:44.708
So the warrant is delivered
to every home in Concord
00:42:44.709 --> 00:42:47.041
by the end of
January, mid-February,
00:42:47.042 --> 00:42:49.249
so that people have
a chance to engage
00:42:49.250 --> 00:42:53.042
in what is it that\'s coming
up at April\'s Town Meeting.
00:42:57.042 --> 00:42:59.833
- Once the warrant
article is sent
00:42:59.834 --> 00:43:04.584
to every household in Concord,
that\'s when the dice is cast.
00:43:08.125 --> 00:43:10.999
- I wanted to start
off by showing you
00:43:11.000 --> 00:43:15.416
this item that appeared in
the Concord Journal last week.
00:43:15.417 --> 00:43:16.125
- Oh, good.
00:43:16.125 --> 00:43:16.667
- It did?
00:43:16.667 --> 00:43:17.250
- And...
00:43:17.251 --> 00:43:18.998
yes, yes, \"Drink
to Your Health\",
00:43:18.999 --> 00:43:20.416
how water is really important.
00:43:20.417 --> 00:43:21.458
- I didn\'t even see that.
00:43:21.459 --> 00:43:23.166
- Well, I\'m hoping
most people didn\'t.
00:43:23.167 --> 00:43:24.167
- Who wrote the article?
00:43:24.168 --> 00:43:27.166
- \"To learn more about
healthy hydration,
00:43:27.167 --> 00:43:30.625
visit www.nestlewaters.com.\"
00:43:30.626 --> 00:43:32.666
- Oh, give me a break.
00:43:32.667 --> 00:43:33.125
- Yeah.
00:43:33.126 --> 00:43:35.291
- Do you think they did
that on purpose because they
00:43:35.292 --> 00:43:36.750
knew of the stirrings going on?
00:43:36.751 --> 00:43:37.250
- Absolutely.
00:43:37.250 --> 00:43:38.250
- I want to see that.
00:43:39.292 --> 00:43:41.124
I\'ve been trying to do
this for three years.
00:43:41.125 --> 00:43:43.666
And I\'m not a little old lady...
00:43:43.667 --> 00:43:44.250
- We know that.
00:43:44.251 --> 00:43:45.625
(LAUGHTER)
00:43:45.626 --> 00:43:48.333
- I mean, it was a
seven vote difference.
00:43:48.334 --> 00:43:52.666
They had 272 votes last year, so
the question really comes down
00:43:52.667 --> 00:43:55.708
to, can they incite any
more kind of response
00:43:55.709 --> 00:43:56.709
from this community?
00:44:01.542 --> 00:44:04.291
- But it just seems like one
of those crazy ideas that\'s
00:44:04.292 --> 00:44:06.583
not going to get very far.
00:44:06.584 --> 00:44:10.124
It\'s too drastic.
00:44:10.125 --> 00:44:15.708
I mean, are people gonna line
up at a hose with a bucket
00:44:15.709 --> 00:44:19.666
and get their
daily water supply?
00:44:19.667 --> 00:44:21.958
No.
00:44:21.959 --> 00:44:23.750
- I just think the
way the world is now,
00:44:23.751 --> 00:44:24.833
people want bottled water.
00:44:24.834 --> 00:44:27.124
A lot of people don\'t drink...
they don\'t want tap water
00:44:27.125 --> 00:44:28.042
to drink.
00:44:28.043 --> 00:44:32.416
It hurts businesses because
the whole country is like this.
00:44:32.417 --> 00:44:34.374
We have bottled water
and that\'s the way it is.
00:44:34.375 --> 00:44:37.416
So unless there\'s a wholesale
change in people\'s ideas about
00:44:37.417 --> 00:44:41.291
that... switching over to glass
or some other way to do it...
00:44:41.292 --> 00:44:44.124
I mean, it\'s just going to hurt
businesses that this happens
00:44:44.125 --> 00:44:47.541
because everything
will have to change.
00:44:47.542 --> 00:44:49.834
The way of life... it\'s
people\'s way of life right now.
00:44:52.375 --> 00:44:53.998
- My name is Wade Rubenstein.
00:44:53.999 --> 00:44:56.791
I\'m the owner of Reasons
To Be Cheerful, a dessert
00:44:56.792 --> 00:44:59.791
cafe in Concord, Massachusetts.
00:44:59.792 --> 00:45:01.666
We use town water.
00:45:01.667 --> 00:45:03.999
In an ice cream shop,
you use a lot of water.
00:45:04.000 --> 00:45:06.291
We use water to,
obviously, keep everything
00:45:06.292 --> 00:45:07.750
cleaned and sanitized.
00:45:07.751 --> 00:45:10.541
We also use water
to make our sorbet,
00:45:10.542 --> 00:45:12.541
so our sorbet uses town water.
00:45:12.542 --> 00:45:14.041
We use water for our coffee.
00:45:14.042 --> 00:45:15.875
We use a lot of water, yeah.
00:45:15.876 --> 00:45:17.998
And we offer water
to our customers.
00:45:17.999 --> 00:45:20.791
We always have a pitcher
or two of filtered tap
00:45:20.792 --> 00:45:23.249
water available to our
customers at any time.
00:45:23.250 --> 00:45:25.875
It exceeds the EPA
and state standards.
00:45:25.876 --> 00:45:28.291
I live in town and I\'m
very proud of our water.
00:45:28.292 --> 00:45:30.625
- My name\'s Maggie St. Jean.
00:45:30.626 --> 00:45:35.249
I am a senior at
Concord-Carlisle High School.
00:45:35.250 --> 00:45:41.833
I have been working with Jill
Appel and Jean on the bill.
00:45:41.834 --> 00:45:43.666
Here you are.
00:45:43.667 --> 00:45:47.124
And having the sign outside
on a hot day like today,
00:45:47.125 --> 00:45:48.875
having free water
refills, I mean,
00:45:48.876 --> 00:45:55.124
that\'s fantastic because we
have such filtered and delicious
00:45:55.125 --> 00:45:59.791
water here in Concord, which
is really just a privilege.
00:45:59.792 --> 00:46:02.249
I mean, I don\'t think
there\'s any necessity
00:46:02.250 --> 00:46:04.291
for bottled water at all.
00:46:04.292 --> 00:46:05.875
- When I was their
age, bottled water
00:46:05.876 --> 00:46:07.791
wasn\'t an issue because
it didn\'t exist.
00:46:07.792 --> 00:46:10.374
We got water out of the tap, we
got water out of the bubbler.
00:46:10.375 --> 00:46:12.082
When I say the word
\"bubbler\" to my kids,
00:46:12.083 --> 00:46:13.917
they look at me
like I\'m from Mars.
00:46:13.918 --> 00:46:15.208
But we had water fountains.
00:46:15.209 --> 00:46:17.625
We had them in school, we
had them in public parks,
00:46:17.626 --> 00:46:19.208
and that\'s where we
turned to for water
00:46:19.209 --> 00:46:20.751
when we were thirsty outside.
00:46:39.584 --> 00:46:40.042
- All right.
00:46:40.043 --> 00:46:43.082
I\'m Debra Stark, and I opened
Debra\'s Natural Gourmet
00:46:43.083 --> 00:46:45.291
in 1989.
00:46:45.292 --> 00:46:47.374
Well, I was brought
up on natural foods
00:46:47.375 --> 00:46:51.291
and natural medicine, and truly
have never known anything but.
00:46:51.292 --> 00:46:52.708
So it\'s always been my passion.
00:46:52.709 --> 00:46:55.458
I was always convinced that
if I can convince the world
00:46:55.459 --> 00:46:58.458
to eat better or to do things
a little differently, that we
00:46:58.459 --> 00:47:01.166
wouldn\'t be in the mess we are
with the health care crisis.
00:47:01.167 --> 00:47:03.875
So that truly has
always been my passion.
00:47:03.876 --> 00:47:08.917
So this is all the plastic
water bottles we have left.
00:47:08.918 --> 00:47:10.750
There\'s so many
restrictions out there
00:47:10.751 --> 00:47:14.666
that don\'t make sense to me,
that are supposed be protecting
00:47:14.667 --> 00:47:16.541
our health and freedom.
00:47:16.542 --> 00:47:18.708
So this is one
that I think truly
00:47:18.709 --> 00:47:22.041
would protect our health and
the future of our planet.
00:47:22.042 --> 00:47:24.333
And who knows what else
that we don\'t know about?
00:47:24.334 --> 00:47:25.250
That\'s what worries me.
00:47:25.251 --> 00:47:27.249
I don\'t know what
we don\'t know yet.
00:47:27.250 --> 00:47:29.708
Look at all... every year,
we find out something that we
00:47:29.709 --> 00:47:30.250
didn\'t know.
00:47:30.251 --> 00:47:33.291
Although my mother used
to know everything.
00:47:33.292 --> 00:47:36.584
(LAUGHTER)
00:47:37.542 --> 00:47:40.166
- Next on the agenda
is Article 32,
00:47:40.167 --> 00:47:46.000
the article on bottled water.
00:47:51.834 --> 00:47:54.750
- Excuse me, I don\'t know if
this is appropriate or not.
00:47:54.751 --> 00:47:59.124
But Mr. Crosby, of
the Crosby Market,
00:47:59.125 --> 00:48:01.875
is afraid of losing
business and...
00:48:01.876 --> 00:48:03.998
- Jean, excuse me just a minute.
00:48:03.999 --> 00:48:06.249
We have citizen comments
later in the agenda.
00:48:06.250 --> 00:48:06.999
Would you like...
00:48:07.000 --> 00:48:08.333
- I just want to leave this...
00:48:08.334 --> 00:48:09.209
- OK.
00:48:09.210 --> 00:48:10.458
- It\'s for your...
00:48:10.459 --> 00:48:11.541
and you can read it.
00:48:11.542 --> 00:48:12.958
- Thank you.
00:48:12.959 --> 00:48:13.626
- Thank you.
00:48:13.627 --> 00:48:16.041
- You\'re welcome.
00:48:16.042 --> 00:48:18.416
- Jean, would you like
to make a citizen comment
00:48:18.417 --> 00:48:20.333
before you leave?
00:48:20.334 --> 00:48:22.416
- Yes.
00:48:22.417 --> 00:48:25.333
Jean Hill, Concord Green.
00:48:25.334 --> 00:48:26.833
- Have a seat, Jean.
00:48:26.834 --> 00:48:28.374
- Oh, yes.
00:48:28.375 --> 00:48:29.584
- So we can hear you better.
00:48:32.626 --> 00:48:37.917
- This letter that I\'ve just
given to Chris explains a way
00:48:37.918 --> 00:48:41.082
that might help...
it\'s to the CEO.
00:48:41.083 --> 00:48:46.750
I wrote a letter to the CEO
and made some suggestions that
00:48:46.751 --> 00:48:52.249
might help them regain
lost revenue if the bottle
00:48:52.250 --> 00:48:58.666
ban passes, and that was
selling reusable bottles
00:48:58.667 --> 00:49:01.041
of various sizes.
00:49:01.042 --> 00:49:02.708
And that\'s what my letter says.
00:49:02.709 --> 00:49:03.667
- Thank you very much.
00:49:03.668 --> 00:49:07.082
Thank you for sharing
it with us tonight.
00:49:07.083 --> 00:49:09.833
- You\'re welcome.
00:49:09.834 --> 00:49:11.875
- This is the same board
that was here last year
00:49:11.876 --> 00:49:13.374
and we did not take
a position on it,
00:49:13.375 --> 00:49:15.667
and I suggest that we not
take a position on it again.
00:49:19.167 --> 00:49:21.666
Individually, I think we all
have strong feelings about it,
00:49:21.667 --> 00:49:26.041
but I think it\'s something that
the community has to decide
00:49:26.042 --> 00:49:27.708
what they value as a community.
00:49:27.709 --> 00:49:31.791
I think the voters have
to make a decision.
00:49:31.792 --> 00:49:32.250
- Yeah.
00:49:32.251 --> 00:49:34.374
I would say that if I wasn\'t
sitting at this table,
00:49:34.375 --> 00:49:35.751
I would probably vote for it.
00:49:38.125 --> 00:49:38.918
- It\'s just...
00:49:38.919 --> 00:49:40.998
it\'s a little
depressing sometimes
00:49:40.999 --> 00:49:45.666
that people don\'t think
of this as a chance
00:49:45.667 --> 00:49:49.166
to step forward and be leaders.
00:49:49.167 --> 00:49:51.416
And they don\'t seem to think.
00:49:51.417 --> 00:49:53.416
They think that we\'re
going to go on the way we
00:49:53.417 --> 00:49:55.416
are right now forever.
00:49:55.417 --> 00:49:56.918
And I don\'t think we are.
00:50:00.834 --> 00:50:04.751
(MUSIC PLAYING)
00:50:21.417 --> 00:50:27.166
- I titled this sermon \"Earth
to Church: Can I Get a Witness?\"
00:50:27.167 --> 00:50:31.416
Let\'s become \"Golden
Rule\" activists
00:50:31.417 --> 00:50:37.875
as we move into new behaviors,
consuming less, sharing more,
00:50:37.876 --> 00:50:44.583
curbing our desire to acquire
by expanding our inner world.
00:50:44.584 --> 00:50:47.750
And on this new Earth,
we must recognize
00:50:47.751 --> 00:50:51.998
that future generations are no
less our neighbors than those
00:50:51.999 --> 00:50:56.208
seated next to us in the pews.
00:50:56.209 --> 00:51:02.998
You might think of this
as Golden Rule 2.0.
00:51:02.999 --> 00:51:03.999
- Please, be seated.
00:51:06.834 --> 00:51:07.709
- You know, the...
00:51:07.710 --> 00:51:10.751
it\'s time to start
villainizing bottled water.
00:51:14.000 --> 00:51:16.333
So I\'m Adriana Cohen.
00:51:16.334 --> 00:51:18.998
I\'d consider myself a good
person and a good mother.
00:51:18.999 --> 00:51:20.333
That\'s not all I
do is mothering.
00:51:20.334 --> 00:51:21.167
I do have a career.
00:51:21.168 --> 00:51:24.124
I am a philanthropist, I
am politically engaged.
00:51:24.125 --> 00:51:27.875
I have a business
background, PR and marketing.
00:51:27.876 --> 00:51:29.999
I also have a strong
fundraising background.
00:51:30.000 --> 00:51:32.208
I do a lot of very
effective fundraising
00:51:32.209 --> 00:51:36.833
for very famous successful
politicians, and charities,
00:51:36.834 --> 00:51:39.082
and nonprofits.
00:51:39.083 --> 00:51:43.333
- This is just a small
shot across the bow
00:51:43.334 --> 00:51:46.791
of the bottled water industry.
00:51:46.792 --> 00:51:48.249
I\'m Mary White.
00:51:48.250 --> 00:51:52.958
I\'ve been living in this
neighborhood in Concord
00:51:52.959 --> 00:51:55.291
for 36 years.
00:51:55.292 --> 00:52:00.583
My first real activism
was in the 1980s.
00:52:00.584 --> 00:52:04.998
- Water is a legal product, and
I think it\'s wrong for people
00:52:04.999 --> 00:52:08.750
to impose and inflict their
own personal political agenda
00:52:08.751 --> 00:52:13.333
on the entire community because
they\'re anti-corporation.
00:52:13.334 --> 00:52:21.166
- I see this issue as a
juxtaposition of two freedoms:
00:52:21.167 --> 00:52:28.708
the freedom to buy what we want
regardless of the consequences,
00:52:28.709 --> 00:52:33.583
or the freedom to choose
not to do that in order
00:52:33.584 --> 00:52:36.666
to protect the
freedom of communities
00:52:36.667 --> 00:52:41.875
to control their own
natural water resources.
00:52:41.876 --> 00:52:48.998
What happens if a water company
drains the water in an area?
00:52:48.999 --> 00:52:52.041
They simply move
on to another area.
00:52:52.042 --> 00:52:54.082
- I can\'t believe someone
would be against that.
00:52:54.083 --> 00:52:55.999
Corporations... I don\'t
care who they are...
00:52:56.000 --> 00:52:57.750
They\'re job creators.
00:52:57.751 --> 00:53:00.666
They create opportunities for
people so that they can live,
00:53:00.667 --> 00:53:02.750
they can feed their families.
00:53:02.751 --> 00:53:08.249
- One of the major problems
with private possession of water
00:53:08.250 --> 00:53:11.291
is it leaves Nature
high and dry.
00:53:11.292 --> 00:53:14.333
Nature cannot defend itself.
00:53:14.334 --> 00:53:16.833
- I mean, what\'s going to happen
next year at Town Meeting?
00:53:16.834 --> 00:53:19.666
Are residents... tax paying
residents who contribute
00:53:19.667 --> 00:53:21.541
so much to the community
in so many ways...
00:53:21.542 --> 00:53:24.917
Going to be ticketed for buying
a product these eco-groups
00:53:24.918 --> 00:53:25.834
don\'t like?
00:53:25.835 --> 00:53:28.833
I mean, that\'s not right
and it\'s not American.
00:53:28.834 --> 00:53:34.041
- Americans buy enough bottled
water in the United States
00:53:34.042 --> 00:53:38.416
in one week to circle
the globe five times.
00:53:38.417 --> 00:53:42.791
40 years ago, this
industry barely existed.
00:53:42.792 --> 00:53:48.458
And that whole industry, which
did not exist 40 years ago,
00:53:48.459 --> 00:53:53.708
is now the third largest
industry in the world
00:53:53.709 --> 00:53:57.000
only behind electricity and oil.
00:54:05.000 --> 00:54:06.999
(CHATTER)
00:54:07.000 --> 00:54:11.459
(MUSIC PLAYING)
00:54:21.459 --> 00:54:23.958
- (SINGING) Got the sugar blues.
00:54:23.959 --> 00:54:29.416
Oh, the sweet sugar blues...
00:54:29.417 --> 00:54:33.958
I love my gal, sweet chickadee.
00:54:33.959 --> 00:54:37.917
Cluck on, gal, and
cut the blues on me.
00:54:37.918 --> 00:54:41.917
I\'m going to Heaven,
I\'m going to bed.
00:54:41.918 --> 00:54:45.374
I\'m going to lay down tonight.
00:54:45.375 --> 00:54:47.416
Now I\'m all confused...
00:54:47.417 --> 00:54:50.458
- There\'s still question about
whether or not the bottle
00:54:50.459 --> 00:54:51.666
itself is a hazard...
00:54:51.667 --> 00:54:52.125
- Right.
00:54:52.126 --> 00:54:53.917
- the chemical
compound of the bottle.
00:54:53.918 --> 00:54:55.374
- It would be really
great if Boston
00:54:55.375 --> 00:54:58.917
had more fountains in the
same way that Paris does,
00:54:58.918 --> 00:55:00.292
if you\'ve ever been to Paris.
00:55:04.876 --> 00:55:07.333
- If you\'re going to take away
the bottled water convenience
00:55:07.334 --> 00:55:10.583
if you\'re going to walk in
the convenience store and grab
00:55:10.584 --> 00:55:12.625
a bottle of water
because you\'re thirsty...
00:55:12.626 --> 00:55:14.333
You need to provide
an alternative.
00:55:14.334 --> 00:55:17.999
In America it\'s
about convenience,
00:55:18.000 --> 00:55:21.750
so we\'re very used to being
able to go anywhere and grab
00:55:21.751 --> 00:55:22.667
what we want.
00:55:22.668 --> 00:55:26.041
This town government is trying
to accelerate the behavior
00:55:26.042 --> 00:55:29.249
by forcing the issue, saying,
\"You know what, we\'re not
00:55:29.250 --> 00:55:30.333
going to sell it anymore.
00:55:30.334 --> 00:55:32.041
You guys are going to
change your behavior.
00:55:32.042 --> 00:55:33.042
Now.\"
00:55:36.959 --> 00:55:40.917
(APPLAUSE)
00:55:40.918 --> 00:55:42.626
- They\'re all ready
for Patriot\'s Day.
00:55:48.250 --> 00:55:53.458
- I think I\'m a little nervous
that some weird stuff is going
00:55:53.459 --> 00:55:56.750
to happen and we\'re
going to have bad luck
00:55:56.751 --> 00:55:58.998
and we\'re going to lose.
00:55:58.999 --> 00:56:02.750
And I hope that\'s not the case
because this is definitely
00:56:02.751 --> 00:56:04.208
our last chance.
00:56:04.209 --> 00:56:06.042
It\'s not going to
happen again next year.
00:56:19.292 --> 00:56:22.833
As an activist, I deal with
disappointment every day.
00:56:22.834 --> 00:56:23.709
You know that.
00:56:23.709 --> 00:56:24.334
- I know, I know.
00:56:24.335 --> 00:56:25.541
- You absolutely know that.
00:56:25.542 --> 00:56:26.000
- I do.
00:56:26.001 --> 00:56:27.958
- Yesterday, I didn\'t
get the support...
00:56:27.959 --> 00:56:29.041
- Same thing for ministers.
00:56:29.042 --> 00:56:30.583
- of the League of Women Voters,
00:56:30.584 --> 00:56:32.667
and they supported us last year.
00:56:34.667 --> 00:56:38.124
My astrological forecast
told me that good fortune
00:56:38.125 --> 00:56:40.666
was heading my way, but
I had to be pushing it.
00:56:40.667 --> 00:56:41.833
(LAUGHTER)
00:56:41.834 --> 00:56:43.583
So I think I\'ve
been able to make
00:56:43.584 --> 00:56:46.708
some inroads with some groups.
00:56:46.709 --> 00:56:49.999
I tend to be action oriented.
00:56:50.000 --> 00:56:53.333
The only way you achieve
meaningful change in society
00:56:53.334 --> 00:56:57.208
today is to get involved
in the political process.
00:56:57.209 --> 00:56:58.875
- And you believe
that, but how would
00:56:58.876 --> 00:57:01.875
you inspire them to
join you in that belief?
00:57:01.876 --> 00:57:03.708
- How do you open
up closed minds?
00:57:03.709 --> 00:57:04.791
I mean, really...
00:57:04.792 --> 00:57:06.416
- That\'s not very
appreciative of you.
00:57:06.417 --> 00:57:07.583
(LAUGHTER)
00:57:07.584 --> 00:57:08.042
- I know.
00:57:08.043 --> 00:57:12.291
- How do you increase
flexibility in tight minds?
00:57:12.292 --> 00:57:15.082
- Well I think you
work incrementally, OK?
00:57:15.083 --> 00:57:19.583
But you push for
something more that\'s
00:57:19.584 --> 00:57:21.291
outside of their comfort zone.
00:57:21.292 --> 00:57:25.124
So yes, seek first to understand
then to be understood.
00:57:25.125 --> 00:57:28.249
But the big issue
really is sometimes
00:57:28.250 --> 00:57:32.209
people just need help to get
out of their comfort zones.
00:57:35.375 --> 00:57:40.041
- These are all quotes
from Henry David Thoreau.
00:57:40.042 --> 00:57:42.166
- The final quote over
there is Thoreau\'s.
00:57:42.167 --> 00:57:44.708
\"Can there be any greater
miracle than for an instant
00:57:44.709 --> 00:57:46.583
for us to look through
each other\'s eyes?\"
00:57:46.584 --> 00:57:47.167
- Right.
00:57:47.168 --> 00:57:50.291
- And I think that\'s
the essence of this.
00:57:50.292 --> 00:57:52.917
There is a water bill to pass.
00:57:52.918 --> 00:57:55.541
There is a huge
environmental opportunity
00:57:55.542 --> 00:57:56.542
in passing that bill.
00:57:56.542 --> 00:57:56.999
- Right.
00:57:57.000 --> 00:58:00.291
- But there\'s just as much
of an opportunity for Concord
00:58:00.292 --> 00:58:03.208
to recognize the diversity
within the community,
00:58:03.209 --> 00:58:08.291
to be able to look at that issue
through someone else\'s eyes.
00:58:08.292 --> 00:58:10.708
There\'s that tension,
being able to stand up
00:58:10.709 --> 00:58:14.583
for what you believe in,
make room for the other.
00:58:14.584 --> 00:58:17.458
And I don\'t know,
there\'s a miracle
00:58:17.459 --> 00:58:18.834
waiting to happen there.
00:58:24.751 --> 00:58:26.625
- We are the home of
Henry David Thoreau.
00:58:26.626 --> 00:58:29.625
He\'s the original
environmentalist.
00:58:29.626 --> 00:58:32.416
So he\'s my favorite
environmentalist.
00:58:32.417 --> 00:58:36.416
This is a guy who truly loved
the environment and nature,
00:58:36.417 --> 00:58:38.833
but wasn\'t profiting off of it.
00:58:38.834 --> 00:58:41.999
- I think if Thoreau
were alive today,
00:58:42.000 --> 00:58:45.208
he would be my
number one supporter.
00:58:45.209 --> 00:58:47.834
- Amazing fellow,
Henry David Thoreau.
00:58:50.375 --> 00:58:54.833
- \"Heaven is under our feet
as well as over our heads.\"...
00:58:54.834 --> 00:58:56.709
\"Walden\" by Henry Thoreau.
00:59:00.042 --> 00:59:03.666
Hi, I\'m Tom Blanding, I\'m
a local Thoreau scholar
00:59:03.667 --> 00:59:08.208
and I\'ve spent my life
studying Henry David Thoreau.
00:59:08.209 --> 00:59:11.999
He\'s what I like to call our
\"philosopher of balance\".
00:59:12.000 --> 00:59:14.124
And sometimes we
think of Thoreau
00:59:14.125 --> 00:59:16.374
as being very radical
in his thought,
00:59:16.375 --> 00:59:20.124
but he\'s calling for a
balance between civilization
00:59:20.125 --> 00:59:20.959
and nature.
00:59:20.960 --> 00:59:24.166
So if he seems extreme
in his position,
00:59:24.167 --> 00:59:28.458
it\'s because we\'ve become
so extreme in ours.
00:59:28.459 --> 00:59:30.583
He\'s best known for
the work \"Walden,\"
00:59:30.584 --> 00:59:33.958
which describes his two years,
two months, and two days
00:59:33.959 --> 00:59:36.082
he lived at Walden
Pond in a little house
00:59:36.083 --> 00:59:38.998
that he built for himself.
00:59:38.999 --> 00:59:42.291
Thoreau affected many
aspects of world culture
00:59:42.292 --> 00:59:44.875
through his writings.
00:59:44.876 --> 00:59:47.249
Martin Luther King
Junior had said
00:59:47.250 --> 00:59:51.958
that Thoreau\'s ideas are more
alive today than ever before.
00:59:51.959 --> 00:59:55.541
Mahatma Gandhi said that
Thoreau had a great influence
00:59:55.542 --> 00:59:58.917
on his movement in India.
00:59:58.918 --> 01:00:01.166
I think what appeals to
me most about Thoreau...
01:00:01.167 --> 01:00:04.999
In broadest terms... would
be his overall worldview,
01:00:05.000 --> 01:00:09.958
his view that this world is
composed of a universal soul
01:00:09.959 --> 01:00:13.833
and nature which expresses
that universal soul.
01:00:13.834 --> 01:00:15.666
- Well of course, the
big thing of his life
01:00:15.667 --> 01:00:19.875
was simplicity,
simplicity, simplicity.
01:00:19.876 --> 01:00:24.041
You should your
count your projects
01:00:24.042 --> 01:00:26.999
in one hand, keep
your life very simple,
01:00:27.000 --> 01:00:29.833
which of course none
of us do nowadays.
01:00:29.834 --> 01:00:30.334
Cluttered up.
01:00:30.335 --> 01:00:34.249
But it\'s a nice
concept to think about.
01:00:34.250 --> 01:00:37.751
(CHATTER)
01:00:43.167 --> 01:00:44.167
- You damn rebels.
01:00:44.168 --> 01:00:46.124
Disperse!
01:00:46.125 --> 01:00:49.625
Disperse, I say!
01:00:49.626 --> 01:00:51.791
Damn you, return to your homes!
01:00:51.792 --> 01:00:53.208
Are you deaf?
01:00:53.209 --> 01:00:56.584
(CROWD ARGUING)
01:00:58.959 --> 01:01:02.583
- They poured their
generous blood like water
01:01:02.584 --> 01:01:05.291
before they knew
whether it would
01:01:05.292 --> 01:01:09.999
fertilize the land of freedom,
or the land of their bondage.
01:01:14.417 --> 01:01:19.708
The war for American
Independence had begun indeed.
01:01:19.709 --> 01:01:23.208
The Regulars will continue
their march to Concord,
01:01:23.209 --> 01:01:24.999
eight miles west.
01:01:25.000 --> 01:01:29.082
At Concord, they will be
forced to begin a rapid retreat
01:01:29.083 --> 01:01:32.791
as colonial opposition stiffens.
01:01:32.792 --> 01:01:34.208
- Fire!
01:01:34.209 --> 01:01:35.209
Huzzah!
01:02:01.292 --> 01:02:04.124
- OK, right here, right
now, I think we\'re
01:02:04.125 --> 01:02:06.416
trying to start a conversation.
01:02:06.417 --> 01:02:11.708
To me, if we do this now,
if we pass this thing now,
01:02:11.709 --> 01:02:13.998
what happens versus
if we don\'t pass it.
01:02:13.999 --> 01:02:16.917
And if we don\'t pass it,
nothing is going to happen.
01:02:16.918 --> 01:02:24.416
- I\'m calling you in support
of the local bottled water ban
01:02:24.417 --> 01:02:28.583
article that\'s coming
up before Town Meeting.
01:02:28.584 --> 01:02:29.584
- Take care, bye-bye.
01:02:33.375 --> 01:02:34.792
I think I\'m going to die.
01:02:42.667 --> 01:02:45.666
- Hi I\'m Steve Weezer, I work
with the Metrowest Daily News.
01:02:45.667 --> 01:02:47.626
This is where we print
the Concord Journal.
01:02:50.584 --> 01:02:53.041
(RINGING)
01:02:53.042 --> 01:02:55.999
- Today\'s worry is what\'s coming
out in the Concord Journal,
01:02:56.000 --> 01:02:57.124
and what\'s going to hit us.
01:02:57.125 --> 01:02:58.875
Because I know there\'s
a bunch of stuff
01:02:58.876 --> 01:03:02.041
that will appear in the
Concord Journal today.
01:03:02.042 --> 01:03:05.374
And I wrote a guest commentary.
01:03:05.375 --> 01:03:07.625
I think that\'s
pretty good, but I
01:03:07.626 --> 01:03:09.458
know that there
are two other guest
01:03:09.459 --> 01:03:13.249
commentaries that are opposed
to the bottled water bylaw.
01:03:13.250 --> 01:03:16.333
And so part of what I
have to do is stop myself
01:03:16.334 --> 01:03:18.583
from freaking out and
saying, oh my god, we\'re
01:03:18.584 --> 01:03:21.166
going to Hell in a hand basket.
01:03:21.167 --> 01:03:23.041
- I was going to do
\"Prohibition is back.\"
01:03:23.042 --> 01:03:25.166
That was going to be my title.
01:03:25.167 --> 01:03:26.750
\"Capping our freedom.
01:03:26.751 --> 01:03:29.541
Prohibition is heavy
handed and goes too far.
01:03:29.542 --> 01:03:32.166
If you don\'t like the idea of
bottled water, don\'t buy it.
01:03:32.167 --> 01:03:33.000
Enough is enough.
01:03:33.001 --> 01:03:35.458
This ban is not an
appropriate avenue
01:03:35.459 --> 01:03:39.708
for attaining sustainability
and infringes on our rights.
01:03:39.709 --> 01:03:41.583
When this issue comes
to a vote in April,
01:03:41.584 --> 01:03:43.208
I hope each resident
of Concord will
01:03:43.209 --> 01:03:45.625
come show their support
for basic civil liberties
01:03:45.626 --> 01:03:48.124
and common sense and
vote against the ban
01:03:48.125 --> 01:03:50.583
on bottled water.\"
01:03:50.584 --> 01:03:51.417
- That\'s great.
01:03:51.417 --> 01:03:52.417
- Thank you.
01:03:52.418 --> 01:03:55.291
I\'ve gotten really
great feedback on this,
01:03:55.292 --> 01:03:56.750
a lot of people.
01:03:56.751 --> 01:03:59.583
How Jean Hill wants to
do it and Jill Appel,
01:03:59.584 --> 01:04:01.249
heavy fisted with
the prohibition...
01:04:01.250 --> 01:04:01.792
- Right.
01:04:01.793 --> 01:04:06.416
- And what my fear is
that if Concord passes
01:04:06.417 --> 01:04:07.998
this bottled water
ban, then there\'ll
01:04:07.999 --> 01:04:09.625
be all these copycat towns.
01:04:09.626 --> 01:04:13.998
- If you just logically
plod through what
01:04:13.999 --> 01:04:17.166
is going to happen as a
result and go then into that,
01:04:17.167 --> 01:04:17.959
it\'s like a tree.
01:04:17.960 --> 01:04:19.998
You go up the
branch, go over here,
01:04:19.999 --> 01:04:21.541
and there\'s going
to be... it just...
01:04:21.542 --> 01:04:22.542
- All these different...
01:04:22.543 --> 01:04:26.374
- You have to look at
all the limbs of what\'s
01:04:26.375 --> 01:04:27.833
going to happen
as a result of it,
01:04:27.834 --> 01:04:30.124
and then see where you are at
the top of the tree at the end
01:04:30.125 --> 01:04:30.792
of the day.
01:04:30.793 --> 01:04:33.998
- Maybe it\'s OK that
Concord is the place where
01:04:33.999 --> 01:04:36.249
it gets talked about
and the pros and cons
01:04:36.250 --> 01:04:37.333
are really laid out there.
01:04:37.334 --> 01:04:40.583
So that everybody in the
country gets educated.
01:04:40.584 --> 01:04:42.750
But if it passes,
that is the wrong...
01:04:42.751 --> 01:04:43.209
- It is.
01:04:43.209 --> 01:04:43.999
- It is the wrong thing.
01:04:43.999 --> 01:04:44.542
- message.
01:04:44.543 --> 01:04:48.166
And it\'s ineffective.
01:04:48.167 --> 01:04:50.208
- I\'m quoted
everywhere in the media
01:04:50.209 --> 01:04:53.998
because people respect my views,
and they want to hear from me.
01:04:53.999 --> 01:04:56.708
And so I appreciate the media
giving me that opportunity
01:04:56.709 --> 01:04:58.416
to express my views.
01:04:58.417 --> 01:05:00.374
I\'m going to be
going on CBS again
01:05:00.375 --> 01:05:03.374
on Monday to talk
about the bottled water
01:05:03.375 --> 01:05:05.333
ban and next steps.
01:05:05.334 --> 01:05:07.249
- We fight against
political correctness
01:05:07.250 --> 01:05:09.791
here on Nightside
at so many levels.
01:05:09.792 --> 01:05:11.333
- The smartest guy on radio.
01:05:11.334 --> 01:05:15.124
- And I want to welcome Adriana
Cohen, a business executive,
01:05:15.125 --> 01:05:16.666
public relations specialist.
01:05:16.667 --> 01:05:18.791
And you are the proud
mom of three kids.
01:05:18.792 --> 01:05:21.124
You don\'t look like you\'re
old enough to have three kids.
01:05:21.125 --> 01:05:22.750
- I\'m a lucky lady.
01:05:22.751 --> 01:05:24.625
- Wow, you\'re busy,
busy, busy, busy.
01:05:24.626 --> 01:05:27.041
We heard about this
battle in Concord,
01:05:27.042 --> 01:05:30.041
and I quite frankly
didn\'t understand.
01:05:30.042 --> 01:05:34.666
I am a huge supporter of
extending the bottle bill.
01:05:34.667 --> 01:05:36.958
Are you familiar with the
bottle bill in Massachusetts?
01:05:36.959 --> 01:05:37.751
- Well, yes...
01:05:37.752 --> 01:05:39.124
- Yes, it applies...
01:05:39.125 --> 01:05:42.333
- But it only has
a $0.05 deposit.
01:05:42.334 --> 01:05:43.292
And that\'s not enough.
01:05:43.293 --> 01:05:44.458
- Well, you know what, Jean?
01:05:44.459 --> 01:05:48.166
You\'re wrong on that because
the recycling of beer bottles
01:05:48.167 --> 01:05:51.458
and beer cans and carbonated
beverages in Massachusetts
01:05:51.459 --> 01:05:53.082
has been a huge success.
01:05:53.083 --> 01:05:55.458
And all we have to do
is apply that to the...
01:05:55.459 --> 01:06:00.917
I\'m with you on applying it
to water bottles, and sports
01:06:00.918 --> 01:06:04.333
drinks, and iced tea,
and everything, Jean.
01:06:04.334 --> 01:06:05.458
- I can\'t...
01:06:05.459 --> 01:06:07.249
look, I\'m 84 years old.
01:06:07.250 --> 01:06:07.792
- Right.
01:06:07.793 --> 01:06:10.458
- I can\'t fight the
whole bottled industry.
01:06:10.459 --> 01:06:12.998
- Well, Jean, I
will stand shoulder
01:06:12.999 --> 01:06:16.541
to shoulder with you, Jean,
and I will be there with you.
01:06:16.542 --> 01:06:17.999
I will be there with you.
01:06:18.000 --> 01:06:20.999
But to focus just on
water bottles, to me,
01:06:21.000 --> 01:06:22.791
is discriminatory.
01:06:22.792 --> 01:06:24.791
- I agree, it\'s very
short-sighted because what
01:06:24.792 --> 01:06:28.249
about all the other dozens and
dozens of beverages that are
01:06:28.250 --> 01:06:29.583
contained in plastic?
01:06:29.584 --> 01:06:30.375
I mean...
01:06:30.376 --> 01:06:34.791
- May I say this, Adriana?
01:06:34.792 --> 01:06:36.958
I assume this is Adriana.
01:06:36.959 --> 01:06:37.834
- Yes, it is.
01:06:37.835 --> 01:06:39.124
- And this is Dan.
01:06:39.125 --> 01:06:40.333
(LAUGHTER)
01:06:40.334 --> 01:06:42.666
- And Dan.
01:06:42.667 --> 01:06:44.208
May I say this?
01:06:44.209 --> 01:06:47.750
What people drink,
what children drink
01:06:47.751 --> 01:06:52.041
is determined by
parental guidance.
01:06:52.042 --> 01:06:54.791
They want their
children to be healthy
01:06:54.792 --> 01:06:57.041
and they don\'t want them
to drink sugary drinks.
01:06:57.042 --> 01:06:59.124
- And you want to take
water away from them, Jean.
01:06:59.125 --> 01:07:00.666
You want to take water.
01:07:00.667 --> 01:07:01.708
You want to take water.
01:07:01.709 --> 01:07:03.833
- You can...
01:07:03.834 --> 01:07:04.834
Concord tap water...
01:07:04.835 --> 01:07:05.875
- You want to take water.
01:07:05.876 --> 01:07:09.291
You want to take water,
the source, the life
01:07:09.292 --> 01:07:13.208
spring of the world, away
from young children, Jean.
01:07:13.209 --> 01:07:14.998
I don\'t understand this.
01:07:14.999 --> 01:07:16.249
- Oh, give me a break.
01:07:16.250 --> 01:07:17.998
You don\'t know what
you\'re talking about.
01:07:17.999 --> 01:07:18.959
- I think I do.
01:07:18.960 --> 01:07:20.541
You know what we
could do maybe, Jean?
01:07:20.542 --> 01:07:23.791
We could have you and Adriana
back in studio together,
01:07:23.792 --> 01:07:25.333
and we could have a
whole hour debate.
01:07:25.334 --> 01:07:26.833
Would you like to do that?
01:07:26.834 --> 01:07:29.416
- I don\'t want to have
anything to do with Adriana.
01:07:29.417 --> 01:07:30.833
- Oh, well that\'s
impolite, Jean.
01:07:30.834 --> 01:07:32.082
- That\'s not nice.
01:07:32.083 --> 01:07:32.626
- I think...
01:07:32.627 --> 01:07:33.917
- That\'s not nice.
01:07:33.918 --> 01:07:34.626
That is not nice.
01:07:34.626 --> 01:07:35.083
- Oh, Jean.
01:07:35.084 --> 01:07:37.416
- You know, Jean, you can\'t
go around disparaging people,
01:07:37.417 --> 01:07:38.334
you know.
01:07:38.334 --> 01:07:38.667
- Well, you know what?
01:07:38.668 --> 01:07:40.333
Jean, if you don\'t want
to come in and share
01:07:40.334 --> 01:07:41.917
the microphone with
Adriana, there\'s
01:07:41.918 --> 01:07:42.998
nothing more that I can say.
01:07:42.999 --> 01:07:44.791
Unfortunately, the one
next thing I have to do
01:07:44.792 --> 01:07:45.751
is say goodnight, Jean.
01:07:45.751 --> 01:07:46.209
OK?
01:07:46.210 --> 01:07:47.625
- All right, good night.
01:07:47.626 --> 01:07:49.082
- Have a great
night, good night.
01:07:49.083 --> 01:07:51.625
If you weren\'t on Adriana\'s
side before that call,
01:07:51.626 --> 01:07:52.542
you have to be now.
01:07:52.542 --> 01:07:52.709
We\'ll be back after this.
01:07:52.709 --> 01:07:53.709
- Oh, boy.
01:07:56.209 --> 01:07:58.958
I think I really screwed up.
01:07:58.959 --> 01:08:02.751
(RADIO PLAYING)
01:08:05.584 --> 01:08:10.249
- Nobody has a sense of urgency
on this environmental stuff.
01:08:10.250 --> 01:08:12.999
You know, the nature of pushing
the edge of the envelope
01:08:13.000 --> 01:08:15.375
is that is you\'re
invariably disappointed.
01:08:18.209 --> 01:08:21.708
This is a perfect way to
respond at a community level
01:08:21.709 --> 01:08:23.333
to the power of corporations.
01:08:23.334 --> 01:08:24.875
Perfect.
01:08:24.876 --> 01:08:27.834
They can\'t f... get
out of their own way.
01:08:49.542 --> 01:08:52.999
(CHATTER)
01:08:58.918 --> 01:09:00.876
- But this is the big
warrant for tonight.
01:09:08.792 --> 01:09:11.833
- Yes, let\'s just focus on this.
01:09:11.834 --> 01:09:12.875
- How do you do, Nora?
01:09:12.876 --> 01:09:14.250
It\'s nice to meet you.
01:09:21.792 --> 01:09:22.709
- OK, good.
01:09:22.709 --> 01:09:23.417
- All right, Jill.
01:09:23.417 --> 01:09:24.417
Don\'t worry.
01:09:26.792 --> 01:09:30.250
(MUSIC PLAYING)
01:09:34.250 --> 01:09:37.791
(BELL RINGING)
01:09:37.792 --> 01:09:39.958
- Good evening,
ladies and gentlemen.
01:09:39.959 --> 01:09:44.041
Welcome to the third night
of Concord Town Meeting.
01:09:44.042 --> 01:09:48.625
This is the 376th
consecutive year
01:09:48.626 --> 01:09:50.833
that the citizens
of Concord have
01:09:50.834 --> 01:09:53.041
met in the spring for
annual Town Meeting.
01:09:53.042 --> 01:09:57.917
I see that a quorum is
present, and I do so declare.
01:09:57.918 --> 01:10:01.082
We have a pre-scheduled
item of high interest.
01:10:01.083 --> 01:10:04.833
Ms. Hill moves that the
town take affirmative action
01:10:04.834 --> 01:10:08.374
on Article 32 as
printed in the warrant.
01:10:08.375 --> 01:10:10.999
- The Board of Selectmen did
not reach a consensus regarding
01:10:11.000 --> 01:10:13.458
Article 32, and is
therefore not making
01:10:13.459 --> 01:10:15.583
a recommendation tonight.
01:10:15.584 --> 01:10:18.082
Our job is to think about
what\'s best for Concord,
01:10:18.083 --> 01:10:20.583
whereas in many ways Article
32 is concerned about what\'s
01:10:20.584 --> 01:10:21.625
best for the world.
01:10:21.626 --> 01:10:23.333
Further, if Article
32 passes, there\'s
01:10:23.334 --> 01:10:24.750
a good chance that
the town would
01:10:24.751 --> 01:10:27.291
be sued on constitutional
and other grounds
01:10:27.292 --> 01:10:29.833
by organizations representing
bottling interests.
01:10:29.834 --> 01:10:31.666
In such litigation,
it\'s likely to be...
01:10:31.667 --> 01:10:33.791
to make the cost of
defense so expensive
01:10:33.792 --> 01:10:36.998
that Concord and other towns
would be cowed into submission.
01:10:36.999 --> 01:10:38.875
Whether we want to
enact a ban, and see it
01:10:38.876 --> 01:10:40.750
through to its
conclusion, depends
01:10:40.751 --> 01:10:42.709
on what we value as
citizens of Concord.
01:10:48.250 --> 01:10:49.917
- Certainly nothing
wrong with plastic.
01:10:49.918 --> 01:10:53.166
And in my impression, there\'s
nothing wrong with water.
01:10:53.167 --> 01:10:54.750
But plastics not going away.
01:10:54.751 --> 01:10:56.333
And what we really
have to do, I think,
01:10:56.334 --> 01:11:00.458
is continue to encourage people
to recycle and educate more.
01:11:00.459 --> 01:11:03.583
I mean, basically, Concord is
the place where it all started,
01:11:03.584 --> 01:11:05.999
where freedom is perhaps
the most important thing.
01:11:06.000 --> 01:11:07.541
I simply hope that
those freedoms
01:11:07.542 --> 01:11:08.833
would be maintained tonight.
01:11:08.834 --> 01:11:09.292
(APPLAUSE)
01:11:09.293 --> 01:11:11.750
- As I said before, there\'s no..
01:11:11.751 --> 01:11:15.208
No demonstrations of
clapping, or hissing.
01:11:15.209 --> 01:11:17.875
Either way, this is a
deliberative body and not
01:11:17.876 --> 01:11:19.374
a pep rally.
01:11:19.375 --> 01:11:22.416
- Mr. Moderator,
ladies and gentlemen,
01:11:22.417 --> 01:11:24.998
I stand alone, but confident.
01:11:24.999 --> 01:11:28.333
I\'ve kept an open mind and
I do speak from the heart.
01:11:28.334 --> 01:11:31.333
The whole country
is watching us now.
01:11:31.334 --> 01:11:35.458
Watch out, watch out.
01:11:35.459 --> 01:11:37.917
- And I\'m a fascist.
01:11:37.918 --> 01:11:39.625
- As a lifetime
Concord resident,
01:11:39.626 --> 01:11:41.166
my husband and I
are both strongly
01:11:41.167 --> 01:11:43.041
against passing this article.
01:11:43.042 --> 01:11:46.416
My strong opposition stems from
the lack of a true cost benefit
01:11:46.417 --> 01:11:48.708
analysis of the
proposed restriction.
01:11:48.709 --> 01:11:51.708
I encourage everyone to
oppose this well-intentioned
01:11:51.709 --> 01:11:53.917
but largely unwise,
ill-conceived
01:11:53.918 --> 01:11:55.833
and potentially harmful bylaw.
01:11:55.834 --> 01:11:56.998
Thank you.
01:11:56.999 --> 01:11:57.834
- Thank you.
01:11:57.834 --> 01:11:58.292
Ms. Cohen?
01:11:58.292 --> 01:11:59.125
- I am against...
01:11:59.126 --> 01:12:00.208
- Hi.
01:12:00.209 --> 01:12:04.583
I\'m against the bottle water
ban because it is prohibition.
01:12:04.584 --> 01:12:07.458
Perhaps you\'ve forgotten the
Declaration of Independence.
01:12:07.459 --> 01:12:10.791
I\'d like to recite a line from
the Declaration of Independence
01:12:10.792 --> 01:12:11.875
to you.
01:12:11.876 --> 01:12:14.833
\"Man has certain
unalienable rights
01:12:14.834 --> 01:12:18.333
to life, liberty and the
pursuit of happiness.\"
01:12:18.334 --> 01:12:20.458
When a person no
longer has the liberty
01:12:20.459 --> 01:12:22.917
to decide for themselves
and their children
01:12:22.918 --> 01:12:25.124
what products they\'re
going to put in their body
01:12:25.125 --> 01:12:26.917
and what products
they\'re going to buy,
01:12:26.918 --> 01:12:28.999
we no longer live
in a free society.
01:12:29.000 --> 01:12:32.082
This reminds me of a country
where dictators dictate...
01:12:32.083 --> 01:12:32.709
- Oh, come on.
01:12:32.709 --> 01:12:33.584
- Please be in order.
01:12:33.585 --> 01:12:36.708
- to the masses what
they\'re allowed to buy.
01:12:36.709 --> 01:12:38.998
I encourage you to think very
carefully about your vote
01:12:38.999 --> 01:12:40.959
tonight because it
infringes upon our freedom.
01:12:44.792 --> 01:12:46.958
- If we could go to
the cafeteria, please.
01:12:46.959 --> 01:12:48.291
- The Declaration
of Independence
01:12:48.292 --> 01:12:49.917
was referenced tonight.
01:12:49.918 --> 01:12:53.249
Clean air and clean water, those
are inalienable rights too.
01:12:53.250 --> 01:12:55.374
We have to make a stand
against this kind of stuff
01:12:55.375 --> 01:12:56.958
at some point.
01:12:56.959 --> 01:12:58.666
In 15 years, in 20
years, communities
01:12:58.667 --> 01:13:00.124
all across the world
are going to be
01:13:00.125 --> 01:13:02.124
doing what we\'re proposing
to do here tonight,
01:13:02.125 --> 01:13:04.998
because it\'s the right thing to
do, it\'s the only thing to do.
01:13:04.999 --> 01:13:06.833
There have been
allusions tonight
01:13:06.834 --> 01:13:08.458
to the revolutions in Concord.
01:13:08.459 --> 01:13:11.082
And those are not out of place,
and I know maybe some of us
01:13:11.083 --> 01:13:12.333
may have heard that tonight
and thought, \"Oh, this
01:13:12.334 --> 01:13:13.998
isn\'t as big as the
American Revolution\",
01:13:13.999 --> 01:13:15.291
or \"This isn\'t the
Literary Revolution.\"
01:13:15.292 --> 01:13:16.042
But you know what?
01:13:16.043 --> 01:13:18.458
We\'re in the midst of an
environmental crisis right now,
01:13:18.459 --> 01:13:20.416
and here is a chance to
do something about it
01:13:20.417 --> 01:13:21.375
right here in Concord.
01:13:21.376 --> 01:13:23.166
Thank you.
01:13:23.167 --> 01:13:24.208
- Thank you, Mr. Goodman.
01:13:24.209 --> 01:13:32.209
And again, please keep your
reactions between your ears.
01:13:32.542 --> 01:13:33.542
Microphone number two.
01:13:35.876 --> 01:13:38.750
- We have a chance here in
Concord to send a message that
01:13:38.751 --> 01:13:41.208
if our legislatures
cannot get the job done,
01:13:41.209 --> 01:13:42.541
we can act locally.
01:13:42.542 --> 01:13:46.082
We can show the way, set the
example, shame the legislators,
01:13:46.083 --> 01:13:48.082
maybe provoke them to act.
01:13:48.083 --> 01:13:49.833
- Thank you very much.
01:13:49.834 --> 01:13:51.041
- In my 11 seconds left...
01:13:51.042 --> 01:13:52.958
- Well we\'ve got so
many people waiting,
01:13:52.959 --> 01:13:55.291
and you had such a
powerful wind up.
01:13:55.292 --> 01:13:58.751
(LAUGHTER)
01:13:59.209 --> 01:14:01.750
If we could go to the
cafeteria, please.
01:14:01.751 --> 01:14:03.999
- These corporations
are drilling
01:14:04.000 --> 01:14:07.625
for water that otherwise
would be flowing for free.
01:14:07.626 --> 01:14:10.333
They\'re spending a lot of
money to tell us how to vote.
01:14:10.334 --> 01:14:13.541
Let\'s not do it their way.
01:14:13.542 --> 01:14:16.833
- The spirit of April 19th
lives on in this town,
01:14:16.834 --> 01:14:20.082
the spirit of creating a
new, more rational and more
01:14:20.083 --> 01:14:21.625
just world.
01:14:21.626 --> 01:14:23.998
Democracy is not just
about consumer freedom,
01:14:23.999 --> 01:14:25.750
it\'s about responsible
self-governance.
01:14:25.751 --> 01:14:26.917
(BELL RINGS)
01:14:26.918 --> 01:14:27.834
Perfect!
01:14:27.835 --> 01:14:30.082
(LAUGHTER)
01:14:30.083 --> 01:14:31.998
- I am a senior at
the high school and...
01:14:31.999 --> 01:14:32.626
- I...
01:14:32.627 --> 01:14:35.041
just to clarify, Mr. Beezey,
are you a registered voter?
01:14:35.042 --> 01:14:35.876
- I am a registered voter, yes.
01:14:35.877 --> 01:14:37.124
- Excellent, thank you.
01:14:37.125 --> 01:14:38.666
- And I\'d like to
remind you guys
01:14:38.667 --> 01:14:41.625
that you guys will not
see the repercussions
01:14:41.626 --> 01:14:45.458
of these carcinogens coming
through our children.
01:14:45.459 --> 01:14:48.708
They will be through my children
and my generation\'s children.
01:14:48.709 --> 01:14:51.541
And so I\'d just like you
to hand down Concord to us
01:14:51.542 --> 01:14:54.541
in a safe, better
organized town.
01:14:54.542 --> 01:14:55.459
Thank you very much.
01:14:55.460 --> 01:14:56.998
- Thank you.
01:14:56.999 --> 01:15:02.666
- We are in the midst of a
major global water shortage.
01:15:02.667 --> 01:15:07.791
The industry is gaining
control of water resources
01:15:07.792 --> 01:15:11.166
at an unprecedented rate.
01:15:11.167 --> 01:15:14.333
This article is revolutionary.
01:15:14.334 --> 01:15:18.709
But Concord, we have
revolution in our genes.
01:15:38.083 --> 01:15:42.124
- To be clear... if you are in
favor of the citizen petition,
01:15:42.125 --> 01:15:45.292
please rise and hold the
ballots up if you would, please.
01:15:55.751 --> 01:15:56.459
Thank you.
01:15:56.460 --> 01:16:01.666
And all who are opposed, please
rise and hold your ballots
01:16:01.667 --> 01:16:04.124
high.
01:16:04.125 --> 01:16:06.667
- I don\'t think I can
stand it if we lose.
01:16:09.626 --> 01:16:10.626
We won\'t lose.
01:16:13.083 --> 01:16:14.083
- It could happen.
01:16:22.042 --> 01:16:23.583
- What do you think?
01:16:23.584 --> 01:16:25.999
- I think there are a
lot of young parents,
01:16:26.000 --> 01:16:29.541
young 30-somethings that showed
up here who don\'t want anybody
01:16:29.542 --> 01:16:31.999
telling them what
they can\'t buy.
01:16:32.000 --> 01:16:34.998
And that they
don\'t care, really,
01:16:34.999 --> 01:16:38.998
about what they\'re
leaving their kids.
01:16:38.999 --> 01:16:40.958
They care about...
01:16:40.959 --> 01:16:41.709
- Convenience.
01:16:41.710 --> 01:16:43.416
- They want to choose
what\'s on the shelf.
01:16:43.417 --> 01:16:45.998
- Yeah, yeah.
01:16:45.999 --> 01:16:47.374
They feel privileged.
01:16:47.375 --> 01:16:48.375
- Yeah.
01:16:52.751 --> 01:16:54.708
I\'ve lost all my fingernails...
01:16:54.709 --> 01:16:56.625
except for that one.
01:16:56.626 --> 01:16:59.541
It\'s just that it\'s
been a bad week.
01:16:59.542 --> 01:17:00.000
- Really?
01:17:00.001 --> 01:17:03.416
(LAUGHTER)
01:17:03.417 --> 01:17:05.541
You\'ve done
everything you could.
01:17:05.542 --> 01:17:06.998
I\'ve done everything I could.
01:17:06.999 --> 01:17:09.166
- Yeah.
01:17:09.167 --> 01:17:11.958
- If it loses, at least
we fought a good fight.
01:17:11.959 --> 01:17:12.959
- Yup.
01:17:15.125 --> 01:17:17.999
- And I\'ll be back next
year, if it does lose.
01:17:18.000 --> 01:17:19.750
- Well I won\'t be
with you, dear.
01:17:19.751 --> 01:17:21.583
I\'ve got to something
different next year.
01:17:21.584 --> 01:17:22.459
- I know.
01:17:22.460 --> 01:17:23.791
- Let\'s win this year, OK?
01:17:23.792 --> 01:17:24.667
- Yeah, I think...
01:17:24.668 --> 01:17:26.584
I think that would
be the best solution.
01:17:38.709 --> 01:17:40.124
(BELL RINGING)
01:17:40.125 --> 01:17:42.750
- Could I have your
attention please?
01:17:42.751 --> 01:17:46.708
In a vote by the moderators
in each of the three rooms,
01:17:46.709 --> 01:17:49.958
and in some case with two
separate counters where
01:17:49.959 --> 01:17:57.959
the counters reach the exact
same number, Article 32...
01:17:59.751 --> 01:18:07.291
403 Yes\', 364 No\'s... passes
by a margin of 39 votes.
01:18:07.292 --> 01:18:07.834
- Yeah!
01:18:07.835 --> 01:18:11.209
(APPLAUSE)
01:18:17.167 --> 01:18:19.125
- Oh, thank God.
01:18:31.999 --> 01:18:33.041
Oh, Jill...
01:18:33.042 --> 01:18:33.584
- All right.
01:18:33.585 --> 01:18:34.750
Good job, dear.
01:18:34.751 --> 01:18:36.374
- Well, listen, I
couldn\'t have...
01:18:36.375 --> 01:18:37.750
I wouldn\'t be here without you.
01:18:37.751 --> 01:18:38.292
You know that.
01:18:38.293 --> 01:18:40.208
- Well, I wouldn\'t be
here without you, honey.
01:18:40.209 --> 01:18:41.998
This is a mutual admiration.
01:18:41.999 --> 01:18:44.374
You\'re the lefty,
I\'m the righty.
01:18:44.375 --> 01:18:45.750
You\'re the creative idea girl...
01:18:45.751 --> 01:18:46.167
- You got the ball rolling...
01:18:46.168 --> 01:18:48.082
- I\'m the practical,
get-it-done girl.
01:18:48.083 --> 01:18:48.999
- She\'s the one...
01:18:48.999 --> 01:18:49.999
- We\'re a perfect match.
01:18:50.000 --> 01:18:51.374
- I know, we\'re a team.
01:18:51.375 --> 01:18:54.208
- You got the ball rolling, and
she grabbed it and ran with it.
01:18:54.209 --> 01:18:55.374
- Yeah, that\'s right.
01:18:55.375 --> 01:18:57.625
- Oh my gosh, it\'s a good
thing I had some free time.
01:18:57.626 --> 01:18:58.459
(LAUGHTER)
01:18:58.460 --> 01:18:59.917
- Well, what are
you going to do?
01:18:59.918 --> 01:19:01.833
Go to Italy with your boyfriend.
01:19:01.834 --> 01:19:02.459
- Oh, all right.
01:19:02.460 --> 01:19:04.166
Well, I\'ve got to
play golf tomorrow.
01:19:04.167 --> 01:19:05.708
And then I\'ve got
to bike on Friday.
01:19:05.709 --> 01:19:07.998
So those are my
next appointments.
01:19:07.999 --> 01:19:09.958
- Well, I think you don\'t
get enough exercise.
01:19:09.959 --> 01:19:11.416
- Yeah, you think?
01:19:11.417 --> 01:19:14.374
I haven\'t recently.
01:19:14.375 --> 01:19:14.918
- Well...
01:19:14.919 --> 01:19:17.333
- All right, let\'s go.
01:19:17.334 --> 01:19:18.875
- Well, I have to
get disconnected.
01:19:18.876 --> 01:19:21.833
- Oh, OK.
01:19:21.834 --> 01:19:23.291
- So I\'m supposed to...
01:19:23.292 --> 01:19:25.833
Cut!
01:19:25.834 --> 01:19:30.124
- Concord Town Meeting, they
voted now to ban plastic water
01:19:30.125 --> 01:19:31.833
bottles.
01:19:31.834 --> 01:19:34.041
Are you kidding me?
01:19:34.042 --> 01:19:34.834
Nope.
01:19:34.835 --> 01:19:37.249
Took them three years, but
apparently they have convinced
01:19:37.250 --> 01:19:40.625
everybody, yes, this is
the scourge of the Earth
01:19:40.626 --> 01:19:44.249
and it\'ll be banned... at least
until somebody a little higher
01:19:44.250 --> 01:19:46.875
up than the Concord Town
Meetings members says \"No,
01:19:46.876 --> 01:19:48.458
that\'s absolutely crazy.\"
01:19:48.459 --> 01:19:51.958
Andrea Cohen has been involved
in this since day one.
01:19:51.959 --> 01:19:53.791
Andrea, good morning.
01:19:53.792 --> 01:19:54.917
- Hi, Jeff, how are you?
01:19:54.918 --> 01:19:56.625
- I\'m doing well, and yourself?
01:19:56.626 --> 01:19:57.666
- I\'m doing great.
01:19:57.667 --> 01:20:00.333
Yeah, actually not doing
great because I\'m bummed out
01:20:00.334 --> 01:20:04.124
that this ridiculous,
overreaching bottled water ban
01:20:04.125 --> 01:20:06.042
took place in
Concord last night.
01:20:17.542 --> 01:20:21.082
- \"On September
5th, 2012, Concord
01:20:21.083 --> 01:20:24.041
became the first
community in the nation
01:20:24.042 --> 01:20:27.458
to approve a ban on
plastic bottles.\"
01:20:27.459 --> 01:20:28.626
We made it to Wikipedia.
01:20:32.083 --> 01:20:36.834
(MUSIC PLAYING)