And Then They Came For Us
- Description
- Reviews
- Citation
- Cataloging
- Transcript
AND THEN THEY CAME FOR US is a cautionary and inspiring tale for all societies. In 1942, President Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066, paving the way for the forced incarceration of 120,000 Japanese Americans. The film educates audiences about the constitutional damage done in the name of national security due to war hysteria and racism. Featuring actor George Takei and others who were incarcerated, rediscovered photos of Dorothea Lange and the story of Fred Korematsu’s long journey to justice, the film brings history into the present, as it follows Japanese Americans speaking out against the current Muslim travel ban and other regressive immigration policies.
Educational Media Reviews Online (EMRO) | Reviewed by Jennifer Dean, Film Editor, Filmmaker, Film Curator
"And They Came for Us is an invaluable tool for teaching about the ethical and legal ramifications of incarcerating citizens without due process strictly based on race; the power of documentation and how images are taken and interpreted; and the history of Japanese Internment Camps in the United States. It also provides a foundation for the genesis of a larger discussion about the demonization of the other and importance of safe guarding civil rights now and in the future."
Educational Media Reviews Online (EMRO) | Reviewed by Sheila Intner, Professor Emerita, Graduate School of Library & Information Science, Simmons College GSLIS at Mt. Holyoke
"This is one of the best documentaries this reviewer has seen, well-edited, well-paced, and forcefully presented, combining live action and archival footage seamlessly woven into a compelling whole."
Seattle University School of Law | Lorraine K. Bannai, Director of Fred T. Korematsu Center for Law and Equality and Author of Enduring Conviction: Fred Korematsu and His Quest for Justice
"This moving film powerfully conveys the story of the mass removal and incarceration of persons of Japanese ancestry during World War II and its haunting continued relevance today. Through the voices of survivors of the camps and poignant contemporary photos, the film helps us understand the human experience of the round-up and imprisonment – not only the confusion, anger, and sense of betrayal felt by those imprisoned, but also their strength and resilience. It also tells how, 40 years later, the community sought and won recognition of the wrong through the redress movement in Congress and coram nobis proceedings in court. And, importantly, it underscores the ways in which the incarceration remains relevant today when the country continues to target communities based on race, national origin, and religion in the name of national security. This remarkable film compels its audiences to understand that the quest for justice is constant and a quest in which every person must participate."
Booklist Online | Candace Smith
"This moving program, which draws parallels between this act and currently proposed immigration restrictions, is a reminder of how easily entire populations can be condemned."
UC Santa Cruz | Scott Rappaport
"Featuring rediscovered photographs by Dorothea Lange, And Then They Came For Us connects history with the present, by retelling this story and then showing Japanese American activists speaking out today against a Muslim registry and travel ban."
Stir | Gail Johnson, Co-Founder and Editorial Director
"And Then They Came for Us takes viewers from one troubling chapter in U.S. history to another. It touches on anti-Muslim sentiment set off by 9/11 and Donald Trump’s 2015 call for a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States. Takei led the response among everyday people to stand in solidarity with Muslim Americans, to protest the Muslim registry, with Japanese-Americans right by their fellow countrypeople’s sides. Set to an original score by composer Tatsu Aoki, And Then They Came for Us reminds that never again means now."
Citation
Main credits
Ginzberg, Abby (film producer)
Ginzberg, Abby (film director)
Ginzberg, Abby (screenwriter)
Schneider, Ken (film director)
Schneider, Ken (editor of moving image work)
Takei, George (on-screen participant)
Ina, Satsuki (on-screen participant)
Other credits
Directors of photography, Ashley James and Vicente Franco; music, Tatsu Aoki.
Distributor subjects
American History; Asian American Studies; Civil & Human Rights; Sociology; Photojournalism; Japanese Internment; Documentary Films; American Studies; Asian-American Studies; Civil Rights; Human Rights; Sociology; PhotographyKeywords
WEBVTT
00:00:00.959 --> 00:00:03.837
(melancholy music)
00:00:19.227 --> 00:00:24.232
- 75 years ago, the FBI began
arresting Buddhist priests,
00:00:24.274 --> 00:00:28.360
Japanese language schoolteachers,
and community leaders.
00:00:28.361 --> 00:00:30.904
Within two months of the U.S. government
00:00:30.905 --> 00:00:34.033
began the mass incarceration
of all Japanese Americans
00:00:34.034 --> 00:00:35.743
from the West Coast.
00:00:35.744 --> 00:00:40.206
- I still remember being
seventeen when 9/11 happened.
00:00:42.584 --> 00:00:47.547
Probably the first allied
solidarity friendship event
00:00:48.590 --> 00:00:51.550
I remember attending at that young age,
00:00:51.551 --> 00:00:54.678
at such a difficult time for our country,
00:00:54.679 --> 00:00:58.766
was hosted by Japanese Americans
in southern California.
00:00:58.767 --> 00:01:00.142
- I think many of us
have been thinking about
00:01:00.143 --> 00:01:02.686
the words of Pastor Martin Niemoller,
00:01:02.687 --> 00:01:05.022
who you remember from World War II.
00:01:05.023 --> 00:01:06.982
- First they came for the Communists
00:01:06.983 --> 00:01:11.988
and I did not speak out,
because I was not a Communist.
00:01:12.197 --> 00:01:15.574
- Then they came to take
away the trade unionists.
00:01:15.575 --> 00:01:17.242
- And I did not speak out,
00:01:17.243 --> 00:01:20.662
because I was not a trade unionist.
00:01:20.663 --> 00:01:24.374
- Then they came to take away the Jews.
00:01:24.375 --> 00:01:27.879
- And I did not speak out,
because I was not a Jew.
00:01:28.880 --> 00:01:31.090
- [Dale] Then they came to take away me,
00:01:31.091 --> 00:01:34.344
and there was no one
left to speak out for me.
00:01:35.595 --> 00:01:38.515
(percussive music)
00:01:53.530 --> 00:01:55.906
- [Reporter] Candidate
Trump first floated the idea
00:01:55.907 --> 00:01:58.951
on Pearl Harbor Day, 2015.
00:01:58.952 --> 00:02:00.744
- Donald J. Trump is calling for
00:02:00.745 --> 00:02:03.330
a total and complete shutdown
00:02:03.331 --> 00:02:05.999
of Muslims entering the United States.
00:02:06.000 --> 00:02:08.418
- [Megan] He\'d support
a mandatory database
00:02:08.419 --> 00:02:10.754
to track all Muslims in the U.S.
00:02:10.755 --> 00:02:13.590
- We\'ve done it with
Iran, back a while ago.
00:02:13.591 --> 00:02:15.217
We did it during World
War II with Japanese,
00:02:15.218 --> 00:02:17.136
which, you know, call it what you will...
00:02:17.137 --> 00:02:17.971
- Come on.
00:02:17.972 --> 00:02:19.596
You\'re not proposing we go back
00:02:19.597 --> 00:02:21.765
to the days of internment camps, I hope.
00:02:21.766 --> 00:02:23.725
- No, no, no, I\'m not
proposing that at all, Megan,
00:02:23.726 --> 00:02:24.561
but what I am saying is that
we need to protect America.
00:02:24.561 --> 00:02:25.436
- [Megan] You should know
better than to suggest that.
00:02:25.437 --> 00:02:26.770
I mean, that\'s the kind of stuff
00:02:26.771 --> 00:02:28.105
that gets people scared, Carl.
00:02:28.106 --> 00:02:28.940
- Right.
00:02:28.941 --> 00:02:30.983
But I\'m just saying there
is precedent for it,
00:02:30.984 --> 00:02:31.818
and I\'m not saying....
00:02:31.819 --> 00:02:33.402
- How dare he?
00:02:33.403 --> 00:02:36.113
That was not a precedent.
00:02:36.114 --> 00:02:40.784
It was a warning that we must
never let that happen again.
00:02:40.785 --> 00:02:43.121
(exploding)
00:02:54.424 --> 00:02:57.050
- No matter how long it may take us
00:02:57.051 --> 00:03:02.015
to overcome this premeditated invasion,
00:03:02.056 --> 00:03:05.225
the American people in
their righteous might
00:03:05.226 --> 00:03:08.020
will win through to absolute victory.
00:03:08.021 --> 00:03:10.480
(applauding)
00:03:10.481 --> 00:03:11.940
- It was a national emergency.
00:03:11.941 --> 00:03:13.108
People were panicked.
00:03:13.109 --> 00:03:15.360
There were stories about submarines
00:03:15.361 --> 00:03:19.031
being off the coast, Japanese submarines.
00:03:19.032 --> 00:03:21.533
- And the Navy Secretary
suggested that there were
00:03:21.534 --> 00:03:26.539
Japanese spies and saboteurs
that aided the enemy attack.
00:03:30.084 --> 00:03:31.460
- I \'member that Sunday morning.
00:03:31.461 --> 00:03:33.337
I will never forget.
00:03:33.338 --> 00:03:36.423
We were working out in the field.
00:03:36.424 --> 00:03:39.343
Turned on the radio, just taking a rest,
00:03:39.344 --> 00:03:42.471
and then it was interrupted
with a news flash,
00:03:42.472 --> 00:03:44.348
Japan is bombing Pearl Harbor,
00:03:44.349 --> 00:03:47.893
and I remember saying, \"What
a stupid thing Japan is doing!
00:03:47.894 --> 00:03:51.397
\"Who do they think they
are, bombing our country?\"
00:03:52.523 --> 00:03:54.316
(melancholy music)
00:03:54.317 --> 00:03:56.860
- The next morning
there was a military man
00:03:56.861 --> 00:03:58.863
in front of our house,
00:03:59.989 --> 00:04:00.865
and then after that,
00:04:00.866 --> 00:04:04.035
we were not allowed to go
beyond a certain block.
00:04:07.830 --> 00:04:09.665
- This is my mom standing in line
00:04:09.666 --> 00:04:12.876
waiting to get her family
number that they would wear
00:04:12.877 --> 00:04:15.922
when they were to show up to
be removed from their homes.
00:04:17.548 --> 00:04:20.259
It\'s a remarkable photo
because it captures
00:04:20.260 --> 00:04:21.843
the expression on her face,
00:04:21.844 --> 00:04:26.181
but also the posters in the
back that notified people
00:04:26.182 --> 00:04:29.060
how many days they had before
they were gonna be removed.
00:04:30.561 --> 00:04:33.481
(melancholy music)
00:04:35.566 --> 00:04:39.070
- Mr. Vice President, Mr. Speaker,
00:04:40.738 --> 00:04:43.115
members of the Senate, of the House....
00:04:43.116 --> 00:04:45.117
- Franklin Delano Roosevelt,
00:04:45.118 --> 00:04:48.704
a great man who did great
things during the depression
00:04:48.705 --> 00:04:53.167
to get us out of that
signed Executive Order 9066.
00:04:54.627 --> 00:04:59.423
This nation was swept up
in war hysteria, racism,
00:04:59.424 --> 00:05:02.093
and the failure of political leadership.
00:05:05.263 --> 00:05:07.764
- [Saburo] I remember we
started to gather anything
00:05:07.765 --> 00:05:11.977
that was Japanese-y,
like magazines, records,
00:05:11.978 --> 00:05:16.024
pictures, anything, and
we started to burn them.
00:05:17.150 --> 00:05:19.652
(eerie music)
00:05:47.347 --> 00:05:50.099
(dramatic music)
00:05:52.477 --> 00:05:57.022
- The media was a primary
disseminator of stereotypes
00:05:57.023 --> 00:06:00.567
of not just Japanese,
but Asians more broadly.
00:06:00.568 --> 00:06:02.861
- [Narrator] Fanatically
convinced that the Japanese family
00:06:02.862 --> 00:06:06.156
was especially created
for one single purpose:
00:06:06.157 --> 00:06:10.494
to crush, to conquer,
and to rule like gods
00:06:10.495 --> 00:06:12.746
over all the other people of the earth.
00:06:12.747 --> 00:06:15.832
- One of the major themes
prior to World War II
00:06:15.833 --> 00:06:19.044
within the media was the Yellow Peril,
00:06:19.045 --> 00:06:21.505
that is, Asians posing as a threat
00:06:21.506 --> 00:06:24.717
to Western civilization and Christianity.
00:06:26.177 --> 00:06:29.054
- We had been depicted
in terms of stereotypes,
00:06:29.055 --> 00:06:32.015
rather unattractive stereotypes:
00:06:32.016 --> 00:06:35.812
comic buffoons, the silent servant,
00:06:37.021 --> 00:06:39.523
the vicious villain.
00:06:39.524 --> 00:06:42.150
The soil was tilled, so to speak.
00:06:42.151 --> 00:06:45.405
- When the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor,
00:06:46.239 --> 00:06:50.283
our West Coast became a
potential combat zone.
00:06:50.284 --> 00:06:52.494
Living in that zone were more than 100,000
00:06:52.495 --> 00:06:54.871
persons of Japanese ancestry,
00:06:54.872 --> 00:06:57.290
two-thirds of them American citizens.
00:06:57.291 --> 00:07:00.460
Military authorities therefore
determined that all of them,
00:07:00.461 --> 00:07:02.755
citizens and aliens
alike, would have to move.
00:07:05.716 --> 00:07:10.554
- And so right after Pearl
Harbor, they had us all register,
00:07:10.555 --> 00:07:12.681
and then shortly after the registry,
00:07:12.682 --> 00:07:14.767
they came down with a curfew.
00:07:17.520 --> 00:07:20.397
- Registration was not benign.
00:07:20.398 --> 00:07:22.190
It provided the infrastructure
00:07:22.191 --> 00:07:24.861
for the mass removal and confinement.
00:07:27.572 --> 00:07:32.577
First was the identification
of you as a marked person.
00:07:32.910 --> 00:07:36.247
Second was the given number, anonymity.
00:07:37.081 --> 00:07:40.418
- And then we discovered that
our bank accounts were frozen.
00:07:41.294 --> 00:07:43.796
We were financially paralyzed.
00:07:45.173 --> 00:07:48.675
And then, the soldiers came to get us.
00:07:48.676 --> 00:07:51.596
(melancholy music)
00:07:52.763 --> 00:07:56.099
And so my brother and I were
gazing out the front window,
00:07:56.100 --> 00:08:00.270
and we saw two soldiers
marching up our driveway.
00:08:00.271 --> 00:08:04.441
They carried rifles with
shiny bayonets on them,
00:08:04.442 --> 00:08:07.987
and literally at gunpoint, we
were ordered out of our home.
00:08:09.113 --> 00:08:11.281
We followed them out onto the driveway,
00:08:11.282 --> 00:08:13.366
and waited for our mother to come out,
00:08:13.367 --> 00:08:17.747
and when she came out, tears
were streaming down her cheeks.
00:08:24.545 --> 00:08:26.463
- [Elizabeth] Dorothea
was asked to photograph
00:08:26.464 --> 00:08:29.216
the evacuation of the Japanese Americans.
00:08:29.217 --> 00:08:31.301
She had done government photography
00:08:31.302 --> 00:08:33.136
before during the depression.
00:08:33.137 --> 00:08:35.430
She took her camera out on the streets,
00:08:35.431 --> 00:08:39.392
first in the city and
then out into the fields,
00:08:39.393 --> 00:08:42.145
where she did Migrant
Mother, with the children
00:08:42.146 --> 00:08:44.065
and the mother who can\'t help them.
00:08:45.191 --> 00:08:48.068
That same sensibility she brought with her
00:08:48.069 --> 00:08:51.363
in her photography of the internment,
00:08:51.364 --> 00:08:54.324
because she was looking
for the human story
00:08:54.325 --> 00:08:58.162
inside of a vast movement of people.
00:08:59.080 --> 00:09:01.999
(melancholy music)
00:09:02.917 --> 00:09:06.920
The government wanted a record
to show that this had been
00:09:06.921 --> 00:09:11.383
a humane process, that it had
been done in an orderly way,
00:09:11.384 --> 00:09:16.304
and that there was nothing
for anyone to complain about.
00:09:16.305 --> 00:09:19.225
(melancholy music)
00:09:22.228 --> 00:09:24.771
Dorothea\'s feelings were very different.
00:09:24.772 --> 00:09:28.733
To her, it was such a
suspension of civil liberties.
00:09:28.734 --> 00:09:30.694
She wanted to do this work. (laughs)
00:09:30.695 --> 00:09:33.572
It\'s not that anybody
was twisting her arm.
00:09:33.573 --> 00:09:36.617
She wanted to do this
to make her own point.
00:09:44.917 --> 00:09:48.169
When Dorothea was seven, she got polio,
00:09:48.170 --> 00:09:51.591
and from that point on,
she became an outsider.
00:09:55.219 --> 00:09:58.889
And that absolutely formed
her life as a photographer,
00:09:59.974 --> 00:10:03.977
and it gave her a tremendous
sympathy for people
00:10:03.978 --> 00:10:05.855
who were struck down by adversity.
00:10:09.400 --> 00:10:10.734
She wanted to make a record
00:10:10.735 --> 00:10:13.069
of what the lives were like for the people
00:10:13.070 --> 00:10:17.366
who were about to face
this extraordinary event.
00:10:23.497 --> 00:10:27.752
Women who had just put up
the last of the laundry.
00:10:30.671 --> 00:10:32.547
Beautiful family homes.
00:10:32.548 --> 00:10:35.925
Making sure the family pets
were in the photograph,
00:10:35.926 --> 00:10:37.427
so that you saw the dog
00:10:37.428 --> 00:10:39.305
that was gonna have to be left behind.
00:10:41.474 --> 00:10:43.726
A farmer the night before internment.
00:10:45.811 --> 00:10:50.607
It\'s so poignant; he\'s left
everything absolutely clean.
00:10:50.608 --> 00:10:53.985
There\'s not, nothing\'s out of place,
00:10:53.986 --> 00:10:55.488
and he\'s gotta walk away.
00:11:15.341 --> 00:11:17.967
- Those photographs are indispensable
00:11:17.968 --> 00:11:22.932
to our historic remembrance
of a really important past.
00:11:26.811 --> 00:11:29.313
I think they speak volumes.
00:11:34.193 --> 00:11:35.819
- The Chinese have a saying,
00:11:35.820 --> 00:11:39.239
one picture is worth a thousand words.
00:11:39.240 --> 00:11:41.908
And those pictures capture
00:11:41.909 --> 00:11:46.288
both the stress and the resilience.
00:11:51.502 --> 00:11:53.753
- Dorothea Lange had photographed my aunt,
00:11:53.754 --> 00:11:57.132
Kimiko Kitagaki, with all her
personal belongings, you know,
00:11:57.133 --> 00:11:59.509
getting ready to go to
Tanforan in San Bruno,
00:11:59.510 --> 00:12:00.886
which was the racetrack.
00:12:02.680 --> 00:12:04.181
They weren\'t set-up pictures.
00:12:05.725 --> 00:12:08.476
She was able to capture
moments in people\'s lives
00:12:08.477 --> 00:12:10.146
when their lives changed forever.
00:12:11.856 --> 00:12:14.734
(melancholy music)
00:12:29.206 --> 00:12:30.623
- The logo stands for our family.
00:12:30.624 --> 00:12:32.584
It\'s the Mochida family logo.
00:12:32.585 --> 00:12:34.544
And I haven\'t seen it on anything else,
00:12:34.545 --> 00:12:38.214
just on pieces of luggage
that we had with us
00:12:38.215 --> 00:12:40.092
when we were sent to camp.
00:12:41.343 --> 00:12:44.596
The fact that my dad put that
symbol on all our luggage
00:12:44.597 --> 00:12:46.431
to me means that the little possessions
00:12:46.432 --> 00:12:48.641
that we were able to take,
that he wanted to make sure
00:12:48.642 --> 00:12:51.061
that we could get them after we were done.
00:13:12.082 --> 00:13:13.918
- We had to leave so much behind.
00:13:15.461 --> 00:13:18.338
My father sold his car for $5.00.
00:13:18.339 --> 00:13:20.590
It was painful.
00:13:20.591 --> 00:13:23.511
(melancholy music)
00:13:41.821 --> 00:13:43.988
Everybody, the whole nation,
00:13:43.989 --> 00:13:48.451
our neighbors were looking
at us with suspicion,
00:13:48.452 --> 00:13:51.705
and fear, and some with outright hatred.
00:13:53.082 --> 00:13:55.416
- [Narrator] Now the actual
migration got under way.
00:13:55.417 --> 00:13:57.377
(upbeat music)
00:13:57.378 --> 00:13:59.295
The Army provided fleets of vans
00:13:59.296 --> 00:14:00.965
to transport household belongings,
00:14:02.758 --> 00:14:05.635
and buses to move the
people to assembly centers.
00:14:05.636 --> 00:14:08.721
The evacuees cooperated wholeheartedly.
00:14:08.722 --> 00:14:11.641
The many loyal among them
felt that this was a sacrifice
00:14:11.642 --> 00:14:14.478
they can make in behalf
of America\'s war effort.
00:14:17.147 --> 00:14:18.773
- This euphemistic language
00:14:18.774 --> 00:14:21.360
distorted what they were doing to us.
00:14:25.990 --> 00:14:28.826
Evacuation rather than forced removal.
00:14:32.705 --> 00:14:36.542
Assembly centers rather
than temporary prison camps.
00:14:40.087 --> 00:14:43.131
- You have confinement
with barbed wire fences
00:14:43.132 --> 00:14:45.049
and armed guards, guns pointing in.
00:14:45.050 --> 00:14:46.467
When your freedom is limited,
00:14:46.468 --> 00:14:49.304
incarceration\'s much more accurate
00:14:49.305 --> 00:14:51.389
about what happened to Japanese Americans
00:14:51.390 --> 00:14:53.183
as opposed to the word internment.
00:14:55.019 --> 00:14:56.519
- [Narrator] Now they
were taken to racetracks
00:14:56.520 --> 00:14:57.937
and fairgrounds, where the Army
00:14:57.938 --> 00:15:00.732
almost overnight had
built assembly centers.
00:15:00.733 --> 00:15:03.985
They lived here until
new pioneer communities
00:15:03.986 --> 00:15:07.363
could be completed on federally
owned lands in the interior.
00:15:07.364 --> 00:15:10.533
- The government narrative
about the incarceration
00:15:10.534 --> 00:15:13.244
was that the Japanese
Americans willingly went
00:15:13.245 --> 00:15:17.457
to these prisons, and what
they didn\'t tell for many years
00:15:17.458 --> 00:15:20.044
were the other stories,
the counter-narrative.
00:15:22.296 --> 00:15:25.256
- In 1942, Fred Korematsu was charged
00:15:25.257 --> 00:15:29.052
with refusing the exclusion
orders, and hid out,
00:15:29.053 --> 00:15:31.971
changed his name, and was arrested
00:15:31.972 --> 00:15:35.224
and then taken to the
horse stalls at Tanforan.
00:15:35.225 --> 00:15:37.936
- People don\'t realize
that my dad was vilified
00:15:37.937 --> 00:15:42.315
from day one of his resistance
of the military orders.
00:15:42.316 --> 00:15:47.321
When he was taken from federal
jail over to the Presidio
00:15:47.571 --> 00:15:50.323
and then over to Tanforan
Detention Assembly Center
00:15:50.324 --> 00:15:54.369
in San Bruno, no one wanted
anything to do with him.
00:15:54.370 --> 00:15:58.122
And they thought that if they
associated with my father,
00:15:58.123 --> 00:15:59.917
that some harm might come to them.
00:16:01.919 --> 00:16:03.879
Not even his brother supported him.
00:16:05.923 --> 00:16:08.591
- [Dale] He challenged his exclusion,
00:16:08.592 --> 00:16:11.886
but the Supreme Court upheld
the government incarceration
00:16:11.887 --> 00:16:15.473
of Japanese Americans,
and his case represented
00:16:15.474 --> 00:16:17.768
one of the worst in
American jurisprudence.
00:16:19.269 --> 00:16:22.563
Uprooting 110,000 Americans
of Japanese ancestry
00:16:22.564 --> 00:16:24.148
without the right to an attorney,
00:16:24.149 --> 00:16:26.610
without a hearing, without
the right to a trial,
00:16:28.070 --> 00:16:30.697
and not one act of espionage or sabotage
00:16:30.698 --> 00:16:33.951
ever being proven against
a Japanese American.
00:16:35.285 --> 00:16:38.205
(melancholy music)
00:16:39.206 --> 00:16:42.125
- What happened to us
didn\'t just suddenly happen
00:16:42.126 --> 00:16:43.585
because of Pearl Harbor.
00:16:45.212 --> 00:16:47.880
There was 40 years of
anti-Japanese movement,
00:16:47.881 --> 00:16:51.551
from the early 1900s, to
get rid of all the Japanese
00:16:51.552 --> 00:16:56.223
on the West Coast, because
of competition and racism.
00:16:58.183 --> 00:17:00.810
90% of all the vegetables in California
00:17:00.811 --> 00:17:03.105
were grown by Japanese American farmers.
00:17:04.481 --> 00:17:09.486
- Their farms were parceled
out and later auctioned,
00:17:10.154 --> 00:17:12.489
to, mainly whites.
00:17:54.156 --> 00:17:55.532
- We were assigned numbers.
00:17:59.828 --> 00:18:02.413
Our family number I still remember,
00:18:02.414 --> 00:18:04.832
one four seven three seven.
00:18:04.833 --> 00:18:07.001
And we were loaded onto buses,
00:18:07.002 --> 00:18:10.379
and then they ushered us to
our first accommodations,
00:18:10.380 --> 00:18:12.381
which it was the stables.
00:18:12.382 --> 00:18:16.136
- Each family then was
assigned one horse stall.
00:18:17.387 --> 00:18:20.932
For my parents to take
their three children
00:18:20.933 --> 00:18:23.893
and crowd into a smelly horse stall
00:18:23.894 --> 00:18:27.397
was a degrading, painful experience.
00:18:30.359 --> 00:18:33.277
- I don\'t think people realized
00:18:33.278 --> 00:18:36.490
the extent to which their
lives were gonna be upended.
00:18:37.491 --> 00:18:39.492
My mother would never have
dreamed that they were gonna be
00:18:39.493 --> 00:18:41.453
incarcerated for four and a half years.
00:18:42.746 --> 00:18:45.624
(melancholy music)
00:18:54.216 --> 00:18:59.054
- My mother, she had a portable
sewing machine, brand new.
00:19:00.639 --> 00:19:02.390
That was forbidden.
00:19:02.391 --> 00:19:05.768
That was contraband, because
we were not to take anything
00:19:05.769 --> 00:19:10.774
that was mechanical or had
sharp points or edges to it.
00:19:10.941 --> 00:19:15.194
My mother smuggled in her
portable sewing machine.
00:19:15.195 --> 00:19:18.990
She marched right past
those armed soldiers
00:19:18.991 --> 00:19:20.826
carrying a contraband.
00:19:29.751 --> 00:19:31.335
- I didn\'t know what we were doing there,
00:19:31.336 --> 00:19:34.088
and I often asked my mother, you know,
00:19:34.089 --> 00:19:35.173
when are we gonna leave,
00:19:35.174 --> 00:19:37.592
when are we gonna go back to Hayward,
00:19:37.593 --> 00:19:38.969
you know, what\'s happening,
00:19:39.803 --> 00:19:41.805
but she couldn\'t answer those questions.
00:20:01.742 --> 00:20:04.785
(train rattling)
00:20:04.786 --> 00:20:06.787
- [George] We were there
at Santa Anita Racetrack
00:20:06.788 --> 00:20:10.666
for a couple of months while
the camps were being built,
00:20:10.667 --> 00:20:12.668
and when the construction was completed,
00:20:12.669 --> 00:20:17.506
they loaded us onto
trains, and transported
00:20:17.507 --> 00:20:19.759
two-thirds of the way across the country
00:20:19.760 --> 00:20:22.595
to the swamps of southeastern Arkansas.
00:20:22.596 --> 00:20:25.098
(eerie music)
00:20:30.354 --> 00:20:34.191
- [Man] It was extremely
difficult being uprooted.
00:20:35.692 --> 00:20:36.943
- [Woman] The temperature soared
00:20:36.944 --> 00:20:40.072
from freezing to over 100 degrees.
00:20:41.365 --> 00:20:43.659
- [Woman] I remember
dust storms all the time.
00:20:44.534 --> 00:20:46.369
- [Woman] When the dust storm would come,
00:20:46.370 --> 00:20:47.663
you couldn\'t breathe.
00:21:04.012 --> 00:21:06.055
- My mother, she wrote in her diary
00:21:06.056 --> 00:21:08.516
about this wind that never stopped,
00:21:08.517 --> 00:21:09.851
about the sand in her face.
00:21:31.748 --> 00:21:33.207
My mother was pregnant here,
00:21:33.208 --> 00:21:36.378
and she gave birth to my brother here.
00:21:40.966 --> 00:21:45.345
It was here that they really
felt the peak of their despair.
00:21:48.140 --> 00:21:51.226
(footsteps grinding)
00:21:57.441 --> 00:22:01.861
When I read her diary, it\'s
one thing, but when I\'m here,
00:22:01.862 --> 00:22:04.406
I feel a whole range of emotions.
00:22:06.992 --> 00:22:11.038
I just, I\'m actually
wanting to feel this wind.
00:22:15.542 --> 00:22:20.505
Yeah, it\'s, that was
what they had, you know.
00:22:26.470 --> 00:22:29.389
(melancholy music)
00:22:38.023 --> 00:22:39.065
- They call it relocation,
00:22:39.066 --> 00:22:41.276
but I call it concentration camp.
00:22:46.406 --> 00:22:48.824
We didn\'t have any heat
in our flimsy barrack.
00:22:48.825 --> 00:22:53.788
My father caught pneumonia,
and, 21 days after we got there,
00:22:53.789 --> 00:22:56.249
he died in a makeshift barrack hospital.
00:23:25.612 --> 00:23:28.531
- Ansel Adams, the great
nature photographer,
00:23:28.532 --> 00:23:32.159
was a friend of the director of Manzanar,
00:23:32.160 --> 00:23:34.370
and was invited to come to the camp
00:23:34.371 --> 00:23:36.580
to photograph the people.
00:23:36.581 --> 00:23:39.583
I was just three years old at the time
00:23:39.584 --> 00:23:41.545
and it happened to be my birthday.
00:23:43.547 --> 00:23:46.006
There\'re basically no cameras in Manzanar,
00:23:46.007 --> 00:23:51.012
so for me, it\'s a memory
of kinda my beginnings.
00:23:53.348 --> 00:23:57.059
This is the only thing I
have during that time period.
00:23:57.060 --> 00:23:59.980
(percussive music)
00:24:09.948 --> 00:24:12.366
- Ansel Adams\'s work is really
important to talk about,
00:24:12.367 --> 00:24:15.703
because when he was brought to the camp,
00:24:15.704 --> 00:24:18.581
he was determined to show
00:24:18.582 --> 00:24:22.751
Japanese residents as human beings,
00:24:22.752 --> 00:24:25.754
and he didn\'t make them look like the rats
00:24:25.755 --> 00:24:27.883
that they were portrayed at the time.
00:24:29.134 --> 00:24:31.218
He was highly criticized
00:24:31.219 --> 00:24:33.847
for showing the enemy as human beings.
00:24:37.434 --> 00:24:40.978
- I thought he was a huge
man with these boots on,
00:24:40.979 --> 00:24:44.273
and there we were, standing and
waiting for school to start,
00:24:44.274 --> 00:24:48.778
and he asked us to be in the picture.
00:24:54.117 --> 00:24:56.327
- People of Japanese
descent were vilified,
00:24:56.328 --> 00:24:59.705
and they were shown as evil caricatures
00:24:59.706 --> 00:25:01.957
and they all had one face.
00:25:01.958 --> 00:25:05.961
And he gave a very individual human face
00:25:05.962 --> 00:25:08.797
to each person he photographed,
00:25:08.798 --> 00:25:11.259
and he photographed almost
everybody in the camp.
00:25:16.515 --> 00:25:20.226
- Nowadays, many critics
excoriate the pictures
00:25:20.227 --> 00:25:25.232
because they feel like he didn\'t
show the hardships of life.
00:25:28.235 --> 00:25:30.069
- There\'s a photograph he took
00:25:30.070 --> 00:25:31.695
of a mother and her daughters,
00:25:31.696 --> 00:25:34.073
and they\'re in very pretty clothes,
00:25:34.074 --> 00:25:37.451
and it just looks like they
have the loveliest little cabin.
00:25:37.452 --> 00:25:40.996
Well, Ansel left out they had the door
00:25:40.997 --> 00:25:43.333
that was at the end of the barrack.
00:25:49.464 --> 00:25:52.216
- Both Ansel Adams and Dorothea Lange
00:25:52.217 --> 00:25:55.219
were forbidden by the
government to photograph
00:25:55.220 --> 00:25:57.806
the barbed wire fence or sentry towers.
00:25:59.808 --> 00:26:02.685
(children shouting)
(bat cracks)
00:26:02.686 --> 00:26:07.439
Those baseball fields were right
near the barbed wire fence.
00:26:07.440 --> 00:26:09.109
That\'s not in the photographs.
00:26:13.029 --> 00:26:15.030
- Dorothea Lange, she\'d
go in the location,
00:26:15.031 --> 00:26:17.116
she\'d have problems
with the administrator,
00:26:17.117 --> 00:26:20.202
trying to get access to
photographing in the camp.
00:26:20.203 --> 00:26:21.912
She had a conflict with them
00:26:21.913 --> 00:26:24.206
\'cause she was showing too much emotion,
00:26:24.207 --> 00:26:25.792
more than they wanted to see.
00:26:27.669 --> 00:26:29.044
- Everywhere she went,
00:26:29.045 --> 00:26:31.255
she was followed by the military police.
00:26:31.256 --> 00:26:34.508
There would be a police
guy accompanying her.
00:26:34.509 --> 00:26:38.304
She would be asked over and
over again to show her papers,
00:26:38.305 --> 00:26:41.056
and they would put her in a
room and tell he she had to wait
00:26:41.057 --> 00:26:43.392
until she could speak
to the military police
00:26:43.393 --> 00:26:44.435
and have her papers checked,
00:26:44.436 --> 00:26:48.147
and she\'d sit there fuming
with her camera in her lap.
00:26:48.148 --> 00:26:50.858
She wanted to get out
there and photograph.
00:26:50.859 --> 00:26:53.737
(melancholy music)
00:26:58.074 --> 00:26:59.783
The government made these
00:26:59.784 --> 00:27:02.037
photographic records for themselves.
00:27:02.871 --> 00:27:05.332
They did not tend to use them publicly.
00:27:06.541 --> 00:27:11.295
Some of them were impounded right away,
00:27:11.296 --> 00:27:15.342
photographs that they
felt looked suspicious.
00:27:16.760 --> 00:27:18.677
For example, the Japanese Americans
00:27:18.678 --> 00:27:21.805
built a lath house for starting seeds.
00:27:21.806 --> 00:27:25.434
Dorothea photographed people
working in these lath houses,
00:27:25.435 --> 00:27:30.440
but the shadows that fell from
the laths made it look like
00:27:30.607 --> 00:27:32.691
they were in prison behind bars,
00:27:32.692 --> 00:27:35.362
and so those were impounded immediately.
00:27:41.409 --> 00:27:43.952
Dorothea\'s photographs
actually after the war
00:27:43.953 --> 00:27:46.081
were put into the National Archives.
00:27:47.666 --> 00:27:50.250
They kind of were buried away
00:27:50.251 --> 00:27:54.631
and nobody saw them for a very long time.
00:27:56.466 --> 00:27:59.093
- I think in retrospect,
the government felt
00:27:59.094 --> 00:28:02.888
that it was a shame and an
embarrassing experience.
00:28:02.889 --> 00:28:06.809
They did not want it
documented or publicized.
00:28:06.810 --> 00:28:10.521
But where there is oppression,
there is resistance.
00:28:10.522 --> 00:28:15.485
Toyo Miyatake, who was a photographer,
00:28:16.319 --> 00:28:21.324
managed to make a box camera
00:28:21.533 --> 00:28:24.744
and sneak in film and take pictures.
00:28:32.127 --> 00:28:35.003
Miyatake took some fantastic photos,
00:28:35.004 --> 00:28:37.173
given the equipment that he had,
00:28:40.260 --> 00:28:44.763
like that iconic photo of
that boy on the barbed wire,
00:28:44.764 --> 00:28:46.850
the forbidden landscape.
00:28:52.772 --> 00:28:57.109
- Cameras were not allowed,
and we could not take pictures.
00:28:57.110 --> 00:29:01.864
My father was able to teach
art because art school
00:29:01.865 --> 00:29:06.870
was open to everyone
and it was a diversion.
00:29:09.831 --> 00:29:13.167
My mother also did
portraits and paintings.
00:29:13.168 --> 00:29:15.502
She painted knowing that they may be
00:29:15.503 --> 00:29:17.881
of historical significance sometime.
00:29:27.223 --> 00:29:28.599
- These were all interesting
00:29:28.600 --> 00:29:30.642
because they were protest messages.
00:29:30.643 --> 00:29:34.022
They were messages against
what was happening to them,
00:29:35.774 --> 00:29:38.734
the anger that they felt
towards the government
00:29:38.735 --> 00:29:40.736
for having done this to them,
00:29:40.737 --> 00:29:43.572
which they couldn\'t
express in public meetings,
00:29:43.573 --> 00:29:45.992
but they felt it very deeply.
00:30:02.467 --> 00:30:04.510
- The government and the Army developed
00:30:04.511 --> 00:30:06.596
what was called the loyalty questionnaire.
00:30:08.139 --> 00:30:09.848
There were a series of questions.
00:30:09.849 --> 00:30:14.019
The most prominent ones
were number 27 and 28,
00:30:14.020 --> 00:30:16.939
and these questions asked
if you would be willing
00:30:16.940 --> 00:30:18.607
to bear arms against the enemy.
00:30:18.608 --> 00:30:21.109
- And will you forswear any allegiance
00:30:21.110 --> 00:30:22.444
to the Emperor of Japan,
00:30:22.445 --> 00:30:25.239
and most of us didn\'t even
know who they\'re talking about,
00:30:25.240 --> 00:30:28.450
and, besides, we\'re Americans,
so why would they ask us
00:30:28.451 --> 00:30:31.161
about the Emperor of Japan?
00:30:31.162 --> 00:30:32.955
- My father said, \"They took my business,
00:30:32.956 --> 00:30:35.999
\"they took our home,
they took our freedom.
00:30:36.000 --> 00:30:38.043
\"Now they want our dignity.
00:30:38.044 --> 00:30:41.213
\"We will not submit to that.\"
00:30:41.214 --> 00:30:43.007
And they both answered no.
00:30:44.509 --> 00:30:46.510
- If you answered yes-yes,
00:30:46.511 --> 00:30:49.638
you were automatically
put in the loyal category,
00:30:49.639 --> 00:30:51.723
which meant then you could be drafted.
00:30:51.724 --> 00:30:55.395
You could also, have clearance
to leave and go back home.
00:30:56.688 --> 00:31:01.149
If you answered no-no, or
if you refused to answer,
00:31:01.150 --> 00:31:04.903
or if you gave a partial
answer, or if you did no-yes,
00:31:04.904 --> 00:31:07.656
then you were all put in
the disloyal category.
00:31:07.657 --> 00:31:10.242
- Disloyal, we, they weren\'t disloyal.
00:31:10.243 --> 00:31:12.411
They were outraged.
00:31:12.412 --> 00:31:15.331
(melancholy music)
00:31:17.000 --> 00:31:19.626
- The government decided that all those
00:31:19.627 --> 00:31:21.128
who were considered disloyal
00:31:21.129 --> 00:31:23.631
needed to be segregated
to a separate prison camp.
00:31:24.632 --> 00:31:29.637
Tule Lake was the camp where 12,000 people
00:31:29.971 --> 00:31:34.349
who protested this ill-conceived,
00:31:34.350 --> 00:31:39.355
incompetently administered
loyalty questionnaire
00:31:39.439 --> 00:31:42.441
ended up being sent to Tule Lake,
00:31:42.442 --> 00:31:45.236
which became a maximum security prison.
00:31:46.321 --> 00:31:50.991
- So now, they\'re gonna treat
them like hardened criminals.
00:31:50.992 --> 00:31:53.368
Three layers of barbed wire fence,
00:31:53.369 --> 00:31:56.914
a half a dozen tanks
patrolling the perimeter.
00:31:56.915 --> 00:32:01.084
- Instead of the standard
eight guard towers,
00:32:01.085 --> 00:32:02.670
there were 24 guard towers.
00:32:04.172 --> 00:32:08.508
It was harder to get coal, it
was harder to have hot water,
00:32:08.509 --> 00:32:11.637
my mother writes about
how difficult it was
00:32:11.638 --> 00:32:13.890
to get enough milk for the children.
00:32:16.851 --> 00:32:21.856
- They forced the internees
to build a cement jailhouse,
00:32:23.316 --> 00:32:25.526
which we referred to as a stockade.
00:32:27.403 --> 00:32:30.238
They were put into that cement jailhouse
00:32:30.239 --> 00:32:32.241
and they were interrogated.
00:32:33.076 --> 00:32:34.869
It was brutal.
00:32:35.745 --> 00:32:39.749
- The stockade imprisoned
over two hundred people.
00:32:40.917 --> 00:32:44.628
They were held for things like being
00:32:44.629 --> 00:32:47.589
too smart for their own good,
00:32:47.590 --> 00:32:51.426
or associates with troublemakers.
00:32:51.427 --> 00:32:53.512
There were no charges.
00:32:53.513 --> 00:32:54.972
There were no sentences.
00:32:54.973 --> 00:32:56.891
Nobody knew why they were in there.
00:32:58.851 --> 00:33:00.018
- My father was a dissident.
00:33:00.019 --> 00:33:02.437
He was opposed to how
they were being treated.
00:33:02.438 --> 00:33:03.897
He was opposed to the fact
00:33:03.898 --> 00:33:06.901
that their Constitutional
rights were violated.
00:33:09.112 --> 00:33:11.989
So my father gives a five-sentence speech
00:33:11.990 --> 00:33:14.908
saying that we need to
ask the U.S. government
00:33:14.909 --> 00:33:17.495
to treat us equal to the free people.
00:33:18.746 --> 00:33:22.290
He was taken, put in
the jail in Tule Lake,
00:33:22.291 --> 00:33:24.711
and then removed to
Bismarck, North Dakota.
00:33:26.629 --> 00:33:28.922
My mother had no idea where he was going,
00:33:28.923 --> 00:33:30.550
what was going to happen to him.
00:33:31.426 --> 00:33:35.178
She says in her diary, I
wonder if today\'s the day
00:33:35.179 --> 00:33:37.098
they\'re gonna line us up and shoot us.
00:33:38.307 --> 00:33:41.227
(melancholy music)
00:33:43.229 --> 00:33:47.775
- The war never ended for
Japanese who were incarcerated.
00:33:50.987 --> 00:33:54.656
Despite being released, given scanty funds
00:33:54.657 --> 00:33:58.160
for their bus ride, there
was considerable anxiety
00:33:58.161 --> 00:33:59.870
and wondering about the neighbors
00:33:59.871 --> 00:34:03.499
and their reception upon coming back.
00:34:15.303 --> 00:34:16.803
- The hardest thing, I think, for me
00:34:16.804 --> 00:34:18.722
was when we came back and were in school
00:34:18.723 --> 00:34:20.849
and were taunted a lot by other students.
00:34:20.850 --> 00:34:24.061
You know, they called us Jap
and made negative remarks
00:34:24.062 --> 00:34:25.897
about how we should\'ve been put away.
00:34:30.026 --> 00:34:32.402
- My sister was a senior,
00:34:32.403 --> 00:34:34.696
and when announcement came for all seniors
00:34:34.697 --> 00:34:36.615
to go to the principal\'s office
00:34:36.616 --> 00:34:38.992
to get their cap and gown measurement,
00:34:38.993 --> 00:34:42.329
she excitedly joined her
classmates and went there,
00:34:42.330 --> 00:34:45.082
and when she got there, the
principal took her aside
00:34:45.083 --> 00:34:47.501
and said, \"We decided
we don\'t want any Japs
00:34:47.502 --> 00:34:49.879
\"at our graduation, so you can\'t attend.\"
00:34:54.634 --> 00:34:59.263
- Our first home was on Skid
Row, downtown Los Angeles.
00:35:02.308 --> 00:35:06.020
My teacher called me the little Jap boy.
00:35:07.563 --> 00:35:09.189
It stung.
00:35:09.190 --> 00:35:11.024
And she was mean to me.
00:35:11.025 --> 00:35:13.360
Occasionally, you know, when
I felt a little confident,
00:35:13.361 --> 00:35:14.903
I would raise my hand.
00:35:14.904 --> 00:35:16.364
She would look the other way.
00:35:18.699 --> 00:35:20.659
By that time, I was getting to understand
00:35:20.660 --> 00:35:24.246
that my parents were very
hurt by the internment,
00:35:24.247 --> 00:35:25.957
and so I didn\'t tell my parents.
00:35:29.085 --> 00:35:30.961
- The camps were closing down.
00:35:30.962 --> 00:35:32.796
People were being released,
00:35:32.797 --> 00:35:36.800
except for those that had
been identified as dissidents.
00:35:36.801 --> 00:35:40.303
So my mother, this was
really one of the most
00:35:40.304 --> 00:35:42.056
heart-wrenching parts of her diary,
00:35:42.890 --> 00:35:45.892
every day she was hoping
that she would be released,
00:35:45.893 --> 00:35:49.146
and every day other people\'s
names were shown on the list
00:35:49.147 --> 00:35:50.523
and her name never came up.
00:35:51.482 --> 00:35:54.443
(melancholy music)
00:36:09.125 --> 00:36:10.792
- [Reporter] In San
Francisco Federal Court,
00:36:10.793 --> 00:36:12.294
an echo from World War II.
00:36:12.295 --> 00:36:15.589
It\'s a sad chapter, the
internment of Japanese Americans.
00:36:15.590 --> 00:36:18.133
At issue today is whether
the U.S. government
00:36:18.134 --> 00:36:21.720
lied about why those Japanese
Americans were put in camps.
00:36:21.721 --> 00:36:24.222
- [Reporter] For forty years,
Fred Korematsu has lived
00:36:24.223 --> 00:36:25.807
with a criminal conviction,
00:36:25.808 --> 00:36:28.602
his name attached to a
landmark Supreme Court ruling
00:36:28.603 --> 00:36:30.937
that in time of war, American citizens
00:36:30.938 --> 00:36:33.565
can be imprisoned on the basis of race.
00:36:33.566 --> 00:36:37.402
In 1942, Korematsu refused
to obey military orders
00:36:37.403 --> 00:36:40.780
interning more than
100,000 Japanese Americans.
00:36:40.781 --> 00:36:42.949
The Army justified the mass imprisonment
00:36:42.950 --> 00:36:46.203
as a military necessity,
citing evidence of espionage
00:36:46.204 --> 00:36:48.622
and sabotage by Japanese Americans,
00:36:48.623 --> 00:36:52.000
including signaling enemy
ships from the West Coast.
00:36:52.001 --> 00:36:54.377
- The government lied
to the Supreme Court.
00:36:54.378 --> 00:36:55.587
They were telling lies
00:36:55.588 --> 00:36:57.672
about the danger of Japanese Americans,
00:36:57.673 --> 00:37:00.842
both about instances of
espionage and sabotage,
00:37:00.843 --> 00:37:05.180
and had altered evidence to
win these cases at all costs.
00:37:05.181 --> 00:37:07.807
So fraud was committed
on the Supreme Court
00:37:07.808 --> 00:37:10.185
in the original decisions
of Korematsu, Hirabayashi,
00:37:10.186 --> 00:37:13.772
and Yasui, which upheld the
government incarceration
00:37:13.773 --> 00:37:15.941
and exclusion of Japanese Americans.
00:37:15.942 --> 00:37:17.692
- [Reporter] Internal documents now reveal
00:37:17.693 --> 00:37:21.029
that at the time, FBI
director J. Edgar Hoove wrote,
00:37:21.030 --> 00:37:22.489
\"in no case has there been
00:37:22.490 --> 00:37:24.991
\"illicit signaling from shore to ship.\"
00:37:24.992 --> 00:37:28.119
- Even J. Edgar Hoover,
no fan of civil rights,
00:37:28.120 --> 00:37:28.955
said that, you know,
00:37:28.956 --> 00:37:30.789
I have files on all the dangerous people.
00:37:30.790 --> 00:37:32.540
He had files on everyone, of course,
00:37:32.541 --> 00:37:35.168
and his conclusion was that we know
00:37:35.169 --> 00:37:37.879
who the dangerous ones are,
and there\'s not very many
00:37:37.880 --> 00:37:39.965
of \'em and we can take care of them.
00:37:39.966 --> 00:37:41.549
- [Reporter] A Justice
Department attorney wrote
00:37:41.550 --> 00:37:43.885
that statements of espionage and sabotage
00:37:43.886 --> 00:37:45.720
are intentional falsehoods.
00:37:45.721 --> 00:37:49.141
- During the war, there were
about 18 spies arrested.
00:37:50.309 --> 00:37:52.645
None of them were of Japanese ancestry.
00:37:53.980 --> 00:37:55.897
- [Reporter] The Enemy
Alien Control Division said,
00:37:55.898 --> 00:37:58.733
\"it is highly unfair
to this racial minority
00:37:58.734 --> 00:38:01.028
\"that these lies go uncorrected.\"
00:38:02.113 --> 00:38:05.032
(melancholy music)
00:38:07.243 --> 00:38:10.161
- The issue before me was
whether the government
00:38:10.162 --> 00:38:12.998
had misrepresented certain facts,
00:38:12.999 --> 00:38:17.419
both to the District Court
and to the Supreme Court.
00:38:17.420 --> 00:38:19.754
- I had to do some real deep thinking
00:38:19.755 --> 00:38:22.966
in order to reopen this case again,
00:38:22.967 --> 00:38:25.885
and I am very happy that I did,
00:38:25.886 --> 00:38:28.763
because this is not only for,
00:38:28.764 --> 00:38:31.599
just the Japanese American citizens,
00:38:31.600 --> 00:38:34.103
but it\'s for all American citizens.
00:38:35.104 --> 00:38:39.816
- In court, I started out
saying, we are here today,
00:38:39.817 --> 00:38:42.610
to seek a measure of justice
denied to Fred Koretmatsu
00:38:42.611 --> 00:38:45.947
and the Japanese American
people some 40 years ago.
00:38:45.948 --> 00:38:47.824
And Fred gave a really strong argument
00:38:47.825 --> 00:38:50.535
about how the last time
he was in this court,
00:38:50.536 --> 00:38:51.704
he was in handcuffs.
00:38:53.164 --> 00:38:58.127
- So the government offered
Mr. Korematsu a pardon.
00:38:59.337 --> 00:39:01.629
I heard Mr. Korematsu
say a couple of times
00:39:01.630 --> 00:39:04.591
that maybe he should have
offered them a pardon, (laughs)
00:39:04.592 --> 00:39:07.552
because they were the ones
that needed to be forgiven.
00:39:07.553 --> 00:39:10.638
- My father never
considered for one minute
00:39:10.639 --> 00:39:12.849
to accept a pardon from the government.
00:39:12.850 --> 00:39:16.436
He was so deep-rooted in his belief
00:39:16.437 --> 00:39:20.607
that the government was wrong
that he would never, ever
00:39:20.608 --> 00:39:22.400
accept a pardon on any condition,
00:39:22.401 --> 00:39:25.820
\'cause a pardon means that you are guilty,
00:39:25.821 --> 00:39:27.698
and he was never guilty.
00:39:29.825 --> 00:39:31.993
- [Dale] There was a crowd
of about 1,000 people,
00:39:31.994 --> 00:39:34.913
many of whom were people
who were incarcerated.
00:39:34.914 --> 00:39:38.500
You could hear them quietly
crying during the hearings.
00:39:38.501 --> 00:39:41.836
The court ruled that there
was no military justification
00:39:41.837 --> 00:39:44.130
for an incarceration
of Japanese Americans.
00:39:44.131 --> 00:39:46.132
- The courtroom just erupted,
00:39:46.133 --> 00:39:49.636
and people came up to
my father and, you know,
00:39:49.637 --> 00:39:53.348
hugged him and congratulated
him and they were all in tears.
00:39:53.349 --> 00:39:55.266
This weight went off his shoulders,
00:39:55.267 --> 00:39:56.852
lifted off his shoulders.
00:39:58.187 --> 00:39:59.771
- This kind of thing should not happen,
00:39:59.772 --> 00:40:04.276
and it should serve as
a warning, to all of us.
00:40:06.862 --> 00:40:11.199
- Even though Judge Patel
overturned my father\'s conviction,
00:40:11.200 --> 00:40:13.410
Korematsu versus United States
00:40:13.411 --> 00:40:16.413
is still on the Supreme Court record.
00:40:16.414 --> 00:40:18.706
It\'s been discredited,
but the Supreme Court
00:40:18.707 --> 00:40:20.333
can only reverse itself.
00:40:20.334 --> 00:40:22.711
And as of today, it has not done so.
00:40:26.549 --> 00:40:28.883
- I was too young to understand,
00:40:28.884 --> 00:40:31.219
but I do remember the barbed wire fence
00:40:31.220 --> 00:40:34.223
from which my parents
warned me to stay away.
00:40:35.182 --> 00:40:38.601
I remember the sight of high guard towers.
00:40:38.602 --> 00:40:41.521
I remember soldiers carrying rifles.
00:40:41.522 --> 00:40:43.607
And I remember being afraid.
00:40:44.733 --> 00:40:47.527
- There was two parts to this.
00:40:47.528 --> 00:40:50.280
One was the reparations of $20,000
00:40:50.281 --> 00:40:52.574
for all surviving members, and then,
00:40:52.575 --> 00:40:54.993
there was the Presidential apology.
00:40:54.994 --> 00:40:59.122
- We gather here today
to right a grave wrong.
00:40:59.123 --> 00:41:00.665
More than forty years ago,
00:41:00.666 --> 00:41:02.750
shortly after the bombing of Pearl Harbor,
00:41:02.751 --> 00:41:06.379
120,000 persons of Japanese ancestry
00:41:06.380 --> 00:41:09.757
living in the United States
were forcibly removed
00:41:09.758 --> 00:41:13.720
from their homes and placed
in makeshift internment camps.
00:41:13.721 --> 00:41:17.098
This action was taken
without trial, without jury.
00:41:17.099 --> 00:41:19.018
It was based solely on race.
00:41:19.977 --> 00:41:22.937
- So my mother got her check, and I said,
00:41:22.938 --> 00:41:24.814
\"I wanna see it before you cash it.
00:41:24.815 --> 00:41:25.774
\"Okay, where\'s the check?\"
00:41:25.775 --> 00:41:28.985
She said, \"It\'s over there, somewhere.\"
00:41:28.986 --> 00:41:33.991
On the wall was framed already
the Presidential apology,
00:41:36.494 --> 00:41:40.121
and somewhere in that pile
was the twenty grand. (laughs)
00:41:40.122 --> 00:41:44.125
And, I said, \"Mom, what\'s it mean to you?\"
00:41:44.126 --> 00:41:47.838
And she said, \"I feel like
I finally got my face back.\"
00:41:48.839 --> 00:41:51.759
(melancholy music)
00:41:58.057 --> 00:41:59.516
- [Richard] Dorothea Lange\'s
always said that she did
00:41:59.517 --> 00:42:02.686
a very bad job of her
incarceration photographs.
00:42:04.563 --> 00:42:06.981
I think it was because it
was such a very difficult
00:42:06.982 --> 00:42:09.651
and sad experience in her
life that she just associates
00:42:09.652 --> 00:42:12.237
her work as not being up to her standards.
00:42:12.238 --> 00:42:14.614
But it was very obvious from
just looking at those pictures
00:42:14.615 --> 00:42:16.158
that she did a great job.
00:42:17.660 --> 00:42:19.619
- [Elizabeth] Dorothea
said, \"On the surface,
00:42:19.620 --> 00:42:21.538
\"it looked like a narrow job.
00:42:21.539 --> 00:42:24.040
\"Actually, it wasn\'t narrow at all.
00:42:24.041 --> 00:42:27.627
\"The deeper I got into
it, the bigger it became.
00:42:27.628 --> 00:42:29.462
\"I never had a comfortable feeling
00:42:29.463 --> 00:42:31.757
\"about that war relocation job.\"
00:42:33.801 --> 00:42:36.970
Because the challenges were
so difficult in the job,
00:42:36.971 --> 00:42:40.848
the way she was really being
stepped on by the government,
00:42:40.849 --> 00:42:45.854
and controlled in what she could
do, it just chafed for her.
00:42:45.980 --> 00:42:49.482
She hated being restricted,
and those kinda restrictions
00:42:49.483 --> 00:42:52.361
meant she couldn\'t get the
photographs she really wanted.
00:42:55.447 --> 00:42:58.117
- Those are like the iconic
images of the internment.
00:42:59.785 --> 00:43:01.828
If we didn\'t have these photographs,
00:43:01.829 --> 00:43:05.331
this story would be a, it\'s
a blip in U.S. history.
00:43:05.332 --> 00:43:07.208
- You know, people look
back and they say, well,
00:43:07.209 --> 00:43:12.214
these things can\'t happen
again, but I don\'t believe that.
00:43:12.840 --> 00:43:16.719
I see, you know, the hysteria over
00:43:20.055 --> 00:43:21.724
people of Muslim faith
00:43:22.641 --> 00:43:27.646
being almost the same level.
00:43:32.151 --> 00:43:34.360
- The Japanese American
community who can speak
00:43:34.361 --> 00:43:38.114
from personal experience, many
of them survivors themselves
00:43:38.115 --> 00:43:41.701
of the internment camps right
here in the United States,
00:43:41.702 --> 00:43:44.412
humanizes the worst case scenario.
00:43:44.413 --> 00:43:47.373
We don\'t have to convince
Japanese Americans
00:43:47.374 --> 00:43:50.418
that national security policy unchecked
00:43:50.419 --> 00:43:54.089
can tear apart our
country\'s Bill of Rights.
00:43:55.883 --> 00:43:58.093
- This was done to us in America.
00:43:59.053 --> 00:44:01.929
And you would think at the
time it was just so horrifying,
00:44:01.930 --> 00:44:04.223
and when I think of my mom
and dad and the sacrifices
00:44:04.224 --> 00:44:05.266
they had to make, and the people
00:44:05.267 --> 00:44:06.934
that lost all their businesses,
00:44:06.935 --> 00:44:10.021
and yet we\'re on the
verge of doing it again.
00:44:10.022 --> 00:44:13.650
- It\'s the same kind of sweeping
generalized condemnation,
00:44:13.651 --> 00:44:16.444
characterization of a group of people.
00:44:16.445 --> 00:44:20.782
We\'re Americans, but we look like
00:44:20.783 --> 00:44:22.283
the people that bombed Pearl Harbor,
00:44:22.284 --> 00:44:25.286
so we got categorized as such.
00:44:25.287 --> 00:44:28.456
(siren wailing)
(helicopter whirring)
00:44:28.457 --> 00:44:31.377
(melancholy music)
00:44:34.380 --> 00:44:35.421
- I turned on the television
00:44:35.422 --> 00:44:40.009
and I watched in horror as
so many different things
00:44:40.010 --> 00:44:42.304
that I loved and believed
in were attacked.
00:44:44.640 --> 00:44:48.184
And I saw my community come under attack,
00:44:48.185 --> 00:44:51.104
people having to line up
outside of immigration buildings
00:44:51.105 --> 00:44:55.817
for special registration,
mosques being targeted,
00:44:55.818 --> 00:44:58.152
all things that hadn\'t
really occurred to me
00:44:58.153 --> 00:44:59.738
growing up in the United States.
00:45:10.791 --> 00:45:12.208
- The day after September 11th,
00:45:12.209 --> 00:45:15.169
the Japanese American
organizations called many of
00:45:15.170 --> 00:45:17.338
the Muslim groups around
the country, and they said,
00:45:17.339 --> 00:45:18.673
we wanna offer you support.
00:45:18.674 --> 00:45:19.842
We\'ve been through this.
00:45:23.345 --> 00:45:25.555
- Camps don\'t happen overnight.
00:45:25.556 --> 00:45:27.890
Mass arrests don\'t happen overnight.
00:45:27.891 --> 00:45:29.183
They\'re a process.
00:45:29.184 --> 00:45:31.644
They begin with the fomenting of hate.
00:45:31.645 --> 00:45:33.563
They\'re followed by government policy
00:45:33.564 --> 00:45:36.232
that collects more
information than they need to,
00:45:36.233 --> 00:45:38.359
and then it\'s slow targeting.
00:45:38.360 --> 00:45:40.236
First we have to find
where the Muslims are.
00:45:40.237 --> 00:45:41.571
Then we have to get them registered.
00:45:41.572 --> 00:45:44.991
Then we send FBI informants
into their mosques.
00:45:44.992 --> 00:45:46.534
Then we come for them.
00:45:46.535 --> 00:45:48.953
- [George] We are standing in solidarity
00:45:48.954 --> 00:45:50.705
with the Muslim community.
00:45:50.706 --> 00:45:52.832
- [Reporter] Actor and
activist George Takei
00:45:52.833 --> 00:45:56.461
unveils a petition signed by
more than 300,000 Americans
00:45:56.462 --> 00:46:00.631
opposing any sort of Muslim
ban by President Trump.
00:46:00.632 --> 00:46:05.094
- We are gonna be relentless
in raising the awareness,
00:46:05.095 --> 00:46:07.389
on the part of Americans.
00:46:11.560 --> 00:46:16.022
National security was used
when Pearl Harbor was bombed
00:46:16.023 --> 00:46:18.983
to incarcerate us, and national security
00:46:18.984 --> 00:46:20.651
is being brought up again.
00:46:20.652 --> 00:46:23.946
They\'re using this false fear
00:46:23.947 --> 00:46:26.449
of national security being in jeopardy.
00:46:26.450 --> 00:46:27.284
- [Man] No wall!
00:46:27.285 --> 00:46:28.409
- [Crowd] Sanctuary for all!
00:46:28.410 --> 00:46:29.410
- No bans!
- No bans!
00:46:29.411 --> 00:46:30.745
- No wall!
- No wall!
00:46:30.746 --> 00:46:32.580
- [Crowd] Sanctuary for all!
00:46:32.581 --> 00:46:33.831
- No bans!
- No bans!
00:46:33.832 --> 00:46:35.166
- No wall!
- No wall!
00:46:35.167 --> 00:46:37.084
- [Crowd] Sanctuary for all!
00:46:37.085 --> 00:46:38.085
- No bans!
- No bans!
00:46:38.086 --> 00:46:39.128
- No wall!
- No wall!
00:46:39.129 --> 00:46:40.797
- [Crowd] Sanctuary for all!
00:46:40.798 --> 00:46:41.632
- No bans!
- No bans!
00:46:41.633 --> 00:46:43.090
- No wall!
- No wall!
00:46:43.091 --> 00:46:45.427
- [Crowd] Sanctuary for all!
00:46:46.762 --> 00:46:49.723
(crowd chattering)
00:46:52.810 --> 00:46:54.602
- [Woman] Okay, let\'s go over there.
00:46:54.603 --> 00:46:56.563
He\'s gonna put it up on the wall, okay?
00:46:57.606 --> 00:46:59.774
- When we see someone being harassed,
00:46:59.775 --> 00:47:01.317
we need to stand up.
00:47:01.318 --> 00:47:03.611
We need to call people out.
00:47:03.612 --> 00:47:05.822
We need to question the hateful speech
00:47:05.823 --> 00:47:07.740
that we may be hearing.
00:47:07.741 --> 00:47:11.285
I know that it can go
against your natural instinct
00:47:11.286 --> 00:47:15.373
to be assertive, to be
proactive in your day-to-day,
00:47:15.374 --> 00:47:17.458
but we need to have each other\'s backs
00:47:17.459 --> 00:47:20.462
because we are always stronger in numbers.
00:47:21.421 --> 00:47:25.132
- For a baby and a wedding
are the only registries
00:47:25.133 --> 00:47:28.095
I support, (cheering)
00:47:30.305 --> 00:47:34.976
and if a Muslim one ever
comes to fruition, sign me up.
00:47:34.977 --> 00:47:37.770
(cheering)
Will you be signing?
00:47:37.771 --> 00:47:40.022
I said, will you be signing?
00:47:40.023 --> 00:47:44.277
(cheering)
\'Cause this is survival.
00:47:44.278 --> 00:47:47.822
- We gotta make sure that
we defend our Constitution,
00:47:47.823 --> 00:47:50.408
that we defend our brothers and sisters
00:47:50.409 --> 00:47:51.869
who are in harm\'s way,
00:47:52.786 --> 00:47:56.415
and we have to make sure that
we defend our own humanity,
00:47:57.624 --> 00:48:00.710
because that\'s really what\'s
at stake in this country.
00:48:00.711 --> 00:48:04.338
- [Zahra] And we will
stand by you to ensure
00:48:04.339 --> 00:48:08.468
that our country\'s history
does not repeat itself.
00:48:10.304 --> 00:48:13.222
Know that I am so grateful for all of you.
00:48:13.223 --> 00:48:15.809
Thank you.
(cheering)
00:48:27.321 --> 00:48:30.741
(percussive jazzy music)